Energy Collective blog power policy climate - the conversation happens here

Thursday, November 09, 2006

Election 2006: An Open Letter to Congress

Federal Energy Policies for a Sustainable Energy Future

With Senator George Allen (R) of Virginia conceding his closely contested race to Democrat Jim Webb, Democrats have now secured control of both branches of Congress in this Tuesday's mid-term elections.

This should be good news for clean energy advocates, as it will create a more favorable atmosphere on Capitol Hill for federal energy legislation aimed at reducing America's dependence on foreign oil and other fossil fuels, reducing our greenhouse gas emissions, and developing our own homegrown renewable resources. Democrats in both the House and the Senate have introduced several smart clean energy policies over the past several years of a Republican-controlled Congress, but none of them ever made it out of committee.

As with many other issues, Democrats must now show that they can indeed lead this country forward on energy policy to create a more secure, healthy and sustainable energy future for the United States (and leading is a lot harder than complaining).

To help them along (as if anyone is really listening to me!), the following open letter suggests several federal-level energy policies that I firmly believe should be implemented in order to help America on the path to a secure and sustainable energy future. Think of this as my 'wish list' for the coming Congressional session.

I know that not all (maybe not any) of these policies will pass, but I am optimistic that we will at least finally see public debate on the floor of the House and Senate focusing on how this country should address concerns about dependence on foreign oil, resource depletion concerns, and greenhouse gas emissions. And perhaps, we will see one or two of these sensible and forward-looking policies enacted as we take a few steps down the path to a sustainable energy future.

An Open Letter to Congress

Dear newly elected and re-elected Democrats in Congress and other Senators and Representatives interested in a secure and sustainable energy future,

On Tuesday, November 7th, the people of this great nation voiced their discontent with the current direction our nation is heading by voting in a new set of leaders and representatives and granting control of both houses of Congress to the Democrats. This is a clear vote of confidence in the platform of the Democratic Party and indicates that Americans are looking for new leadership and new strategies in the war in Iraq, a stronger economy (that actually benefits real working Americans), a higher minimum wage, expanded health care coverage and many other issues.

It should also be considered a clear indication that Americans want to see new leadership, new solutions, and new action to address a strong and growing concern for people across the United States: our energy future.

We want leaders who will craft smart policies to ensure a secure, affordable, healthy and sustainable energy future for all Americans. We want to see Congress pass energy legislation that will address our depenence on foreign oil, rising gas prices, resource depletion concerns, and global warming. We want our energy spending to support people and jobs right here in the United States, not line the pockets of Saudi princes, Russian oil barons, or even our oil-exporting neighbors in Canada and Mexico. We're tired of fighting wars and supporting dictators and getting into international entanglements to secure our oil interests overseas. And we want to know that we can feel proud leaving a clean, secure and healthy energy future for our children and grandchildren.

And we're tired of waiting, tired of rhetoric, and tired of empty words. We want action, and we want it soon. And it's up to you.

I would like to bring to your attention the following policy suggestions that would each help address the concerns many Americans have about our dependence on foreign oil, our depleting fossil resources and our growing greenhouse gas emissions. I would strongly encourage that some or all of these policies are implemented in the near future to help set America on a course for a secure, affordable and sustainable energy future:

  • Enact a nationwide Renewable Energy Standard (also known as a Renewable Portfolio Standard) that would require utilities across the United States to include a certain portion of renewables in their energy mix by a given target year. I would suggest a target of 15-25% of their resource mix by 2020 or 2025.

    21 states and the District of Columbia have already enacted Renewable Energy Standards at a state level, and these policies have been proven to be effective and efficient ways to gaurantee the development of our abundant homegrown renewable energy resources and ensure that we accrue the public health, economic development and energy security benefits of tapping our domestic renewable resources.

  • Enact strong nationwide appliance efficiency standards and building efficiency codes. These could be modeled after state-level standards in California and other states that have been very succesful in conserving the energy we use in our homes, offices and industries.

    High performance buildings, energy efficient appliances and lighting and other cost-effective efficiency measures should be harnessed across the country so that by 2025, we consume at least 10% less energy in our homes and businesses than we do now.

  • Raise or reform the Corporate Average Fuel Economy Standards for light-duty vehicle fuel economy so that the average fuel economy of the light vehicle fleet reaches 30 mpg by 2015-2020 and 40 mpg by 2025-2030.

    This would raise the fuel economy of the average car or light truck by about 50% in 2015-2020 and by almost 100% by 2025-2030 compared to the Energy Information Administration's business-as-usual forecasts, resulting in huge savings in imported oil use and large reductions in greenhouse gas emissions from the light vehicle fleet.

  • Close the flex-fuel vehicles loophole in CAFE which creates a large incentive for automakers to manufacturer gas-guzzling flex-fuel SUVs that hardly ever actually run on E85, and end the tax incentives for businesses to purchase large SUVs

    Both of these loopholes in current policies result in increased fuel consumption and greater dependence on foreign oil. According to a NY Times piece written by Thomas Friedman, the E85/CAFE loophole "increased U.S. oil consumption by 80,000 barrels per day in 2005 alone." [see this for more]

  • Enact minimum fuel economy standards for different weight classes to suplement CAFE and end the 'buy a hybrid, sponsor a hummer' syndrome in current CAFE rules.

    Currently, since CAFE is an average fuel economy standard only, progress in fuel economy on the leading edge of an auto manufacturers weight classes explicitly condones the sale of more gas guzzlers on the trailing edge of that weight class. For each fuel efficient Escape Hybrid Ford Motor Company sells, they can sell one more gas guzzling Ford Explorer or F250, eroding the progress made by the expanding adoption of hybrid vehicles. Enacting a sensible minimum fuel economy standard for different weight classes of vehicles would ensure that when energy conscious consumers buy hybrids or other fuel efficient vehicles, they aren't simply allowing carmakers to sell another Hummer or Escalade. The minimums should progressively increase as the average fuel economy standard increases over time.

  • Double or triple the federal energy research budget and focus research spending on basic research into carbon-free and/or renewable technologies and fuels, advanced batteries (for plug-in hybrids and electric vehicles), light-weight vehicle chassis, fuel efficient technologies, carbon sequestration, etc.

    Current spending, now at just $3 billion per year, is sorely lacking. The New York times recently reported that annual United States federal spending on all energy technologies, not just climate friendly ones, has fallen from an inflation-adjusted peak of $7.7 billion in 1979 to just $3 billion in the current budget. In contrast, federal spending on medical research has nearly quadrupled since 1979 and military spending has gone up 260% since then to $75 billion a year - over 20 times what is spent on energy research. If we are serious about energy independence, fighting global warming, and creating a new energy future, we've got to start spending some serious money to tackle these problems.

  • Enact a variable rate gas or oil tax that ensures that either gas prices or oil prices do not fall below a certain floor (say $2.50/gallon for gas or $45.00/barrel for oil, adjusted over time for inflation). This would provide investment certianty for alternatives to oil and ensure that America isn't lulled into inaction if gas or oil prices temporarily fall. While prices may dip and fall temporarily, high oil and gas prices will be the norm in coming decades, and it's time we plan for such a future.

    Part of the money raised could offset income taxes for low-income taxpayers who will be hit disproportionately hard by this tax, while the remainder could fund the increased energy research budget suggested above.

  • Fund public-private partnerships to accelerate commercialization of plug-in hybrids, with the goal of getting them on the market by 2010.

    Plug-in hybrids are an excellent near-to-medium-term solution to our oil dependence, reduce our transportation energy consumption and can harness a diverse range of electricity-producing resources to fuel transportation, including our abundant domestic renewable energy supplies. Plug-ins are nearly ready for mass commercialization and an extra push from a public-private parternship could greatly accelerate their deployment.

  • And finally, (and this is the big one!), enact a nationwide, economy-wide carbon cap and trade system with the goal of reducing national GHG emissions to 2000 levels or below by 2015, to 1990 levels by 2020, at least 15% below 1990 by 2025, and at least 60% below 1990 levels by 2050 (or some other similar targets).

    This is the linchpin policy in the fight against global warming and is long overdue. The other policies described above will be key in achieving the emissions reductions targets, while the cap and trade system will provide the proper market incentives to ensure that they are met. Cap and trade systems have already been implemented to effectively and efficiently reduce several kinds of pollutant emissions from power plants (i.e., SO2, NOx and Mercury) and would be an effective policy mechanism to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

    Additionally, several states are already implementing statewide or regional carbon cap and trade systems in the absence of federal action. This could eventually lead to a hodge-podge of state and regional policies that could create unfair competitive environments for our country's businesses. A national cap and trade system would create a level playing field, which is why more and more big business and industry leaders are asking for a federal carbon cap and trade system.

    Enacting this policy sooner, rather than later, even if caps don't go into effect until later years is also desirably as it would provide industry and business with regulatory certainty and allow smart investment and planning decisions. The current 'wait-and-see' stance in industry is creating large uncertainty and hampering investments in clean energy resources.

    Congress should also immediately pass a resolution or issue a public statement that any pulverized coal plants built after this point in time will not be 'grandfathered' into upcoming carbon regulations.

    Many utilities and power plant developers are planning to construct traditional, dirty, pulverized coal-fired power plants across the United States - over 150 such plants have been proposed in the West - under the assumption that if these plants are constructed before the enactment of carbon legislation, they will be 'grandfathered in' and will avoid regulation. This cannot be the case. The construction of dozens of new pulverized coal-fired power plants - the worst contributors to greenhouse gas emissions - will set the United States back decades in our efforts to control our growing emissions of greenhouse gases and avoid the worst effects of global warming.

    Issuing a clear and public statement to utilities and power plant developers that they should not expect their proposed plants to avoid regulation will provide a clear signal to utilities and developers that building these new plants carries high risks due to upcoming carbon regulations. This should dissuade and prevent the proposed coal building boom now planned across the United States. Utilities and power plant developers should be building power plants that can exist in a carbon-constrained world and should plan accordingly. If we still want to utilize our large domestic coal reserves, we should turn to coal gasification combined cycle power plants - the so-called 'clean coal' technologies - that can capture and sequester carbon emissions safely in geological formations.


  • Members of Congress, it's time for you to lead this great nation into a new energy future: a future where we break our addiction to foreign oil, where we become world leaders in advanced energy technologies, where we create tens of thousands of new jobs and strengthen our economy by developing our abundant homegrown renewable energy resources, where we need not fear the potentially devastating effects of global warming, and where we have created a clean, healthy, secure and sustainable energy future that we can feel proud to leave to our children and grandchildren.

    This is the future that Americans demand! It's up to you to lead us there. A sustainable energy future is possible, and with smart policies and committed leadership, we can make it happen.

    Sincerely,

    Jesse Jenkins
    ____________________
    Concerned citizen and resident of Portland, Oregon

    Read more!

    Election 2006: California's Oil Tax/Alternative Energy Fund Proposition Fails


    Worries about pump prices and bureaucracy doomed Prop. 87, according to observers.

    [From the LA Times:]

    After months of being hammered with threats of higher gas prices at the pump, voters yielded to concerns about Proposition 87 and turned down the proposed tax on crude oil, supporters and opponents agreed Wednesday.

    The "no" side swept most parts of the state with 54.7% of the vote. The "yes" side received 45.3%, carrying only Los Angeles County, the Bay Area and a handful of Northern California counties.

    "Voters were interested in the specifics of the proposal, and the more they looked for details, they found flaws," said Al Lundeen, spokesman for Californians Against Higher Taxes, the "no" campaign.

    Proposition 87 spokeswoman Beth Willon conceded that the opposition — mainly oil companies — was "able to plant seeds of doubt on the issues of cost and accountability."

    The initiative sought to levy a tax of 1.5% to 6% on the price of every barrel of oil pumped from a California well. The estimated $4 billion that would have been raised over 10 years was to be given as grants to scientists and universities or as subsidies to industries for developing nonpolluting alternatives to petroleum.

    The argument over whether a tax on oil company production would be passed along to motorists dominated television commercials since early spring.

    The oil industry spent about $95 million to back Californians Against Higher Taxes. Meanwhile, supporters at Californians for Clean Energy raised $57 million. The battle was the most expensive in California initiative history.

    Proponents of Proposition 87 knew from the start that the potential impact of the tax on retail gas prices could be an issue. With that in mind, they included a provision in the initiative that made it illegal to pass the tax along to motorists, and they highlighted the provision in their ads.

    But that assurance never seemed to persuade voters. Analysts said that despite extensive television exposure, proponents never could overcome people's concerns that Proposition 87 would affect "what he or she pays at the pump" just as gasoline prices are coming down, said Larry N. Gerston, a political science professor at San Jose State.

    Many voters also were apparently swayed by the oil companies' contention that the initiative would create an unaccountable bureaucracy to pass out grants and subsidies from the proceeds of the extraction tax.

    "Bureaucracy is a bad word anywhere," Gerston said.

    The barrage of televised criticism made it hard for the "yes" campaign to get its message across "to make the value of our initiative clear to the voters," said Anthony Rubenstein, a Los Angeles community organizer who had the idea for Proposition 87.

    Election day exit polls conducted by the Los Angeles Times Poll indicated that a majority of votes cast "were all about the money" that motorists feared they might have to pay because of a new tax, said poll Director Susan Pinkus.

    In the poll, 79% of Republican voters opposed Proposition 87, and only 65% of Democrats supported it. Independent voters were split, while majorities of men and women voted no. White voters opposed the measure, while Latinos were split and Asians and blacks voted yes, the poll said.

    Propelled primarily by the personal wealth of Hollywood producer Stephen L. Bing, and combined with campaigning by former President Clinton and a bevy of movie stars, the campaign couldn't allay voters' skepticism and the fear of higher gas prices sowed by oil company advertisements.

    Environmentalists placed much of the blame for their defeat on being outspent two to one by the oil industry.

    "The take-home lesson here is that with $100 million and scaremongering tactics, it's hard to fight," said Roland Hwang, a San Francisco-based official with the Natural Resources Defense Council.

    But political observers countered that the loss couldn't be written off solely due to a lack of money.

    The campaign should have been able to take advantage of the many Californians who worry about pollution and global warming, and harbor deep suspicions of international petroleum corporations, said Julie Buckner, a Los Angeles media consultant involved in the early stages of the Proposition 87 campaign.

    "The campaign had enough resources to win. But it didn't do a good enough job of raising doubts about who was the opposition," Buckner said.

    Indeed, some of the pro-Proposition 87 ads that ran earlier in the campaign featured "windmills and clean air" and were not aggressive enough in criticizing oil companies for allegedly keeping America dependent on petroleum, said Terry Tamminen, who recently resigned as a top environmental advisor to Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger. "Those arguments needed to be made sooner," he said.

    Meanwhile, the oil companies that bankrolled the opposition campaign — mainly Chevron Corp. and Aera Energy LLC, a joint venture of Exxon Mobil Corp. and Royal-Dutch Shell — were careful to stay out of the campaign limelight, referring all campaign queries to their political consultants and allies in the California Chamber of Commerce.

    Environmentalists, though disappointed with Proposition 87's defeat, said they remained hopeful that the fight over the initiative may have stoked people's interest in combating the nation's dependence on polluting oil from overseas and California's oilfields.

    Hwang of the Natural Resources Defense Council said: "Everyone agrees that we've got to figure out a way to solve this problem."

    Read more!

    Election 2006: Clean Energy Candidates Win Across West

    Voters in several Western states chose to elect candidates from both parties that support clean energy in this Tuesday's mid-term elections.

    These results highlight the many opportunities to enact clean energy legislation throughout the West in the coming years as supportive governors and state legislators take (or return to) office throughout the region. Advocates of a clean energy future can expect to see a number of new public policies that promote rural economic development, stable-cost energy resources and environmentally friendly renewable energy project development throughout the region.

    Below is a brief summary of winning candidates and issues from yesterday's election results in the West:

    Oregon

    Ted Kulongoski (D) reelected governor 51% to 42% over Republican challanger, Ron Saxton.

    In his words:

    "[W]e ... need a strategy to make Oregon a national leader in alternative and renewable energy. I'm working on several fronts to achieve this goal. My proposal calls for 25 percent of Oregon's total electricity to come from renewable sources by 2025. A renewable energy portfolio has proved to spur renewable energy production, help the environment, and create family-wage jobs.

    Biofuels: My plan capitalizes on emerging "bio-energy" markets, particularly biodiesel and ethanol, to make Oregon a global leader in biofuel production.

    Conservation: Conservation is highly effective in reducing energy consumption. That's why I've more than tripled the state's flex, biofuel and alternative fuel vehicles and will continue to promote innovative technologies that provide savings and economic opportunities.

    Tax credits to support new investment in renewable energy: I am pursuing a variety of tax incentives to encourage investments in renewable energy technologies, including an increase in the Oregon Business Energy Tax credit from 35 percent to 50 percent and in the eligible cost from $10 million to $20 million per project." [From OregonLive.com 2006 Voters Guide interview with Governor Kulongoski]

    Washington

    Senator Maria Cantwell (D) was solidly reelected 57% to 39% over challanger Mike McGavick.

    In her words:
    "Washington State can be a leader in renewable energy industries and create thousands of new jobs right here at home. ... We need to develop more alternative sources of energy, including wind, to create a better, safer, more prosperous future for all our families." [From a Cantwell campaign ad]

    Arizona

    Janet Napolitano (D) re-elected governor, 63% to 35%, over challenger Len Munsil (R)

    In her own words:
    "Arizona could be the next Persian Gulf of solar energy...We average well over 320 days of sunshine per year, and that's one of our greatest resources, and we ought to use it." [Comments at North American Energy Summit, Albuquerque, N.M., 16 April 2004]

    Arizona Corporation Commissioner Kris Mayes (R) re-elected with 26% of vote (highest of five candidates; top two voter-getters take office).

    In her own words:
    "This [Arizona's new 15% renewable energy standard] is a vote for more jobs in rural Arizona, a healthier water supply, and a more secure electrical grid. Move over California: with these rules we are making Arizona the solar energy capital of the world once again!" [Comments delivered while voting for Arizona's new Renewable Energy Standard and Tariff at the Arizona Corporation Commission, 31 October 2006]

    Arizona Corporation Commissioner candidate Gary Pierce (R) elected with 25% of vote (second-highest of five candidates; top two vote-getters take office)

    In his own words:
    "I don't have a problem with 2025 [target date for Arizona's new Renewable Energy Standard and Tariff], but 15 percent is an arbitrary number. We need a goal, but should recognize it's variable. Let's see how the new rules impact the utility industry, and if they cause significant cost increases (for the consumer). Let's watch it year to year and do whatever is reasonable and responsible." [From 12 October 2006 interview with the Tucson Weekly ]

    Colorado

    Bill Ritter (D) elected governor, 56% to 41%, over challenger Bob Beauprez (R)

    In his own words:
    "We believe that the 'Colorado Promise' is about the new energy economy where this state, Colorado, is a leader in renewable energy, in wind, solar and biofuels." [From acceptance speech, 7 November 2006]

    Local Ballot Issues:

    Boulder voters back carbon tax, 58% to 42%.

    Funds will go toward new Climate Action Plan (CAP) programs, such as helping businesses obtain Xcel rebates for purchases of energy-efficient hardware, performing energy audits to help people understand how they can save energy, and assisting low-income citizens by distributing energy efficiency kits. [See article in today's Colorado Daily.]

    Carbondale (Colo.) voters approve, 81% to 19%, a measure allowing the town to issue up to $1.8 million in Clean Renewable Energy Bonds to build and operate two large-scale solar systems.

    Nevada

    Jim Gibbons (R) elected governor, 50% to 46%, over challenger Dina Titus (D)

    In his own words:
    "I believe we can turn Nevada into an energy independent state. In Congress, I re-wrote the Geothermal Steam Act, essentially making it economically feasible to harvest one of our state's most abundant forms of energy. As governor, I would continue to make geothermal power, as well as solar and wind power, economically attractive. These clean energy sources would give Nevadans independence from other states and other countries that currently supply us. They would also stabilize our utility bills while those around us fluctuate with world events."
    [From statement by Jim Gibbons in 6 November 2006 Rebel Yell]

    New Mexico

    Bill Richardson (D) re-elected governor, 68% to 32% over challenger John Dendahl (R)

    In his own words:
    "[Wind energy] is a good example of how New Mexico is becoming a national leader in clean energy. Since I became Governor, we've started requiring utility companies to produce ten percent of their energy through renewable sources. We've eliminated the state sales tax on hybrid cars and offered a solar tax credit. Clean energy is the key to holding down gas prices, ensuring our national security and creating the jobs of the future." [From Richardson campaign commercial]

    Utah

    Utah did not have a gubernatorial election yesterday. However, the two legislators who plan to carry a state renewable energy tax credit in the 2007 legislature were both re-elected:

    Senator Howard Stephenson (R-Draper) defeated Adam Ford, 65% to 35%
    Rep. Sheryl Allen (R-Bountiful) defeated Richard Watson (D), 68% to 27%

    Wyoming

    Dave Freudenthal (D) re-elected governor, 70% to 30%, over challenger Ray Hunkins (R)

    In his campaign's words:
    "Gov Dave's priorities for a second term are to continue to promote the culture of bipartisan and statewide cooperation --- and to make permanent the smart investments made toward a stable future for Wyoming: Development on Wyoming's Terms...
    · Protect Wyoming's natural treasures
    · Get full value for our minerals by encouraging development of powerlines, powerplants, pipelines, clean coal technologies and alternative energy within Wyoming
    · Additional funding for wildlife habitat and migration corridor protection
    · Diversify Wyoming's economy"

    Voters Make Their Voice Clear: We Want a Clean Energy Future!

    I'm sure that there are many more clean energy champions out there that I missed. I encourage any of you readers to mention them in comments here if you know of any other newly elected or reelected public servants that have pledged to work hard to promote a clean energy future at the local, state or national level.

    By supporting these candidates, voters across the West, and indeed across the United States, have made their voices clear in this election: we want representatives that will fight for clean, homegrown renewable energy that creates jobs here our communities, provides us with safer, more stable and more secure energy, and helps create a clean and healthy future for ourselves and our children!

    We'll need the hard work and support of all of these clean energy champions in the years ahead to craft smarty public policies that will help bring about the much-needed transition to a sustainable energy future!

    I'd encourage you to write letters to your own representatives to make sure they know you expect them to fight for a sustainble energy future. If they are one of these clean energy champions, they'll be glad to hear you reaffirm their stance, and if they aren't on this list, perhaps if they hear a call for clean energy from enough of their constituents, they'll be on this list next year!

    [A hat tip to Craig Cox, Executive Director of the Interwest Energy Alliance for providing the results for all the states excepting Oregon and Washington. Photo credit: Leon Werdinger, October 2006]

    Read more!

    Wednesday, November 08, 2006

    Election 2006: Clean Energy Initiative Leading in Washington State

    Initiative 937 currently leading by 5 points with 60% of votes tallied

    Washington State's Clean Energy Initiative, I-937, appears to be passing, as votes are tallied in the Evergreen State. With about 60% of votes tallied (as of 4:00 pm Pacific Time), I-937 leads 52.5% to 47.5% and is tracking to pass as the final votes are tallied this evening.

    If enacted, as it appears it will be, I-937 would require the 17 largest utilities in Washington state to meet 15% of their electricity demand with new renewable energy resources by the year 2020, with gradually increasing targets in the interim years (3% in 2012 and 9% in 2016). The Initiative would also require affected utilities to harness all cost-effective energy efficiency and conservation opportunities within their service territories.

    About one third of the outstanding votes are from King County (the Seattle/Tacoma area) which has been tracking 60-40 in support of the bill, while the remaining uncounted votes are largely from counties that have been tracking at 50% or more of voters approving the Clean Energy Initiative.

    The Seattle Post-Intelligencer had this to report:

    Initiative 937, an energy efficiency initiative setting new conservation goals for utility companies, held a comfortable lead across the state Tuesday. With many more ballots still to be counted in King County, the measure seemed sure to pass.

    Rep. Jay Inslee, D-Wash., a supporter of the initiative, said its success will grease the wheels for national legislation.

    "Now we're going to move in Washington (D.C.)," he said.

    The initiative would require utilities with 25,000 or more customers -- currently 17 of the state's 63 utilities, including Seattle City Light and Puget Sound Energy -- to meet specific renewable energy goals.

    The measure calls for the larger utilities by 2020 to get 15 percent of their energy from renewable sources -- primarily wind -- or from other sources including solar, wave or tidal power and methane captured from landfills and dairy cow manure.

    But many utilities objected, saying they want to determine what is best for their utility.
    Initiative 937 was a hard fought race with key opposition coming from the pulp and paper industry (including Weyerhauser, Boise Cascade and others), the Association of Washington Businesses, a few utilities (including Avista Corp. and PacifiCorp/Pacific Power), and a few large industrial utility customers (specifically Boeing).

    Proponents of the Initiative included a broad coalition of ratepayer advocacy, environmental, public health and other public interest groups, as well as the Washington Public Utility Association, several elected officials, and many more. U.S. Representative Jay Inslee of Washington, who easily won reelection on Tuesday, deserves special mention as the Initiatives most vocal and public supporter.

    I-937's fight was made all the more difficult by a long and confusing ballot title which left voters unsure about what the initiative would do if enacted. Polls repeatedly showed that when voters knew that a vote for I-937 supported the development of clean, renewable energy and energy efficiency, support for the Initiative was very strong.

    Still, despite the confusing ballot title and the well-funded opposition, Washington voters appear to have approved the Clean Energy Initiative, clearly articulating their preference for a clean energy future for the state.

    Washington will join 20 other states and the District of Columbia that already have renewable energy standards on the books. Two other states have soft renewable energy goals.

    The passage of Initiative 937 in Washington, as well as the solid reelection of Oregon's Governor Ted Kulongoski yesterday, will lend momentum to a proposal to enact a Renewable Energy Standard in neighboring Oregon. The Standard, proposed and backed by Governor Kulongoski, as well as a broad coalition of public interest and environmental groups, would enact a 25% by 2025 renewable energy target. Stakeholder discussions are currently underway to draft legislation which will be submitted to the Oregon legislature before the 2007 session begins in January.

    The favorable national election results for the Democratic Party may also mean that we will see energy legislation addressing renewable energy and energy independence at the federal level in the coming months. Several Democratic leaders have proposed energy legislation in the past while the House and Senate were under Republican control, only to have their 'energy independence' bills stall in committee [see this previous post for one of many examples]. With Democrats now controlling the agenda in the House, and - pending the outcome of the closely contested race in Virginia - in the Senate as well, 'energy independence' legislation will likely make its way to the House and Senate floor.

    All in all, the results of yesterday's mid-term elections are quite favorable for renewable energy advocates across the country. Stay tuned ... this should be an interesting next couple of years!

    Resources:

  • Text of Initiative 937


  • [Full disclosure: my employer, the Renewable Northwest Project is a principle sponsor of I-937 and key supporter of the proposed Oregon Renewable Portfolio Standard.

    I am personally more excited to write this post than any other I have written since starting this blog!

    This is truly an important victory for a clean energy future in the Pacific Northwest!

    Thank you to all of you out there who supported Initiative 937 in one way or another. This was a truly close race, and all of your efforts were key to securing this clean energy victory!
    ]

    Read more!

    Saturday, November 04, 2006

    Atmospheric Concentrations of Greenhouse Gases Reach New Heights in 2005

    [From Green Car Congress:]

    In 2005, the globally averaged concentrations of the greenhouse gases carbon dioxide (CO2) and nitrous oxide (N2O) reached new highs with CO2 at 379.1 parts per million (ppm)—up 0.53% from 377.1 ppm in 2004—and N2O at 319.2 parts per billion (ppb), according to the 2005 Greenhouse Gas Bulletin, published by the World Meteorological Organization (WMO).

    Methane (CH4) concentrations were unchanged at 1,783 ppb. These values are higher than those in pre-industrial times by 35.4%, 18.2% and 154.7%, respectively. After water vapor, carbon dioxide, methane (CH4) and nitrous oxide (N2O) are respectively the three most prevalent greenhouse gases in the Earth’s atmosphere.

    The recently introduced NOAA Annual Greenhouse Gas Index (AGGI) shows that from 1990 to 2005 the atmospheric radiative forcing by all long-lived greenhouse gases has increased by 21.5%. The AGGI increased by 1.25% from 2004 to 2005.

    [Graphic: Changes in atmospheric radiative forcing by long-lived greenhouse gases and the 2005 NOAA Annual Greenhouse Gas Index (AGGI). Click to enlarge.]

    Radiative forcing is the change in the balance between radiation coming into the atmosphere and radiation going out. A positive radiative forcing tends on average to warm the surface of the Earth, and negative forcing tends on average to cool the surface.

    The 35.4% rise in carbon dioxide since the late 1700s has largely been generated by emissions from the combustion of fossil fuels. Around one third of N2O discharged into the air is a result of human activities such as fuel combustion, biomass burning, fertilizer use and some industrial processes.

    Human activity such as fossil fuel exploitation, rice agriculture, biomass burning, landfills and ruminant farm animals account for some 60% of atmospheric CH4, with natural processes including those produced by wetlands and termites responsible for the remaining 40%.

    Accurate atmospheric observations from some 44 WMO Members are archived and distributed by the World Data Centre for Greenhouse Gases (WDCGG), located at the Japan Meteorological Agency.

    WMO prepares the Greenhouse Gases Bulletin in cooperation with WDCGG and the Global Atmosphere Watch Scientific Advisory Group for Greenhouse Gases with the assistance of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's Earth System Research Laboratory.

    Resources:

  • WMO Greenhouse Gas Bulletin

  • Read more!

    Thursday, November 02, 2006

    E3's 'Integrated Biorefinery' to Start Production Soon

    [From RenewableEnergyAccess.com:]

    The first closed-loop system for distilling commercial quantities of ethanol using methane gas recaptured from cow manure is set to begin production next month in Mead, Nebraska. The plant's technology will virtually eliminate the need for fossil fuels in the production of ethanol.

    The 'closed-loop' system - derived from an exclusive patent co-owned by an affiliate of E3 BioFuels - combines a 25-million-gallon per year ethanol refinery, beef cattle feedlot and anaerobic digesters to maximize energy efficiencies unavailable to each component on a stand-alone basis.

    This system eliminates the potential for manure to pollute watersheds, and it enables the wet distiller's grain from ethanol production to be fed on-site to cattle without energy-intensive drying and transportation costs.

    In the October edition of Wired Magazine, venture capitalist Vinod Khosla wrote, "It may surprise you to learn that the most promising solution to our nation's energy crisis begins in the bowels of a waste trough, under the slotted concrete floor of a giant pen that holds 28,000 ... beef cattle."

    Khosla, co-founder of Sun Microsystems, continues, "E3 BioFuels is about to fire up the most energy efficient corn ethanol facility in the country: a $75 million state-of-the-art biorefinery ... The output: a potential gusher of renewable, energy-efficient transportation fuel."

    [Graphic: The E3 Biofuels ethanol refinery in Mead, Nebraska, will begin production in December 2006. The refinery houses anaerobic digesters, a manure lagoon, feedlot and nutrient recovery unit]

    "The Genesis plant at Mead will be the first to market ethanol produced from closed-loop, self-sustaining ethanol technology by at least a year or two, in comparison to any other competitors," said Dennis Langley, Chairman and CEO of E3 BioFuels. "This plant will make ethanol more than twice as energy-efficient as any other method of producing ethanol or gasoline."

    E3 BioFuels-Mead has named the plant Genesis to celebrate that it's the first commercially viable facility on the planet to use this new technology - which officially begins production in December 2006 - as well as signifying the birth of a revolution in energy production.

    "This is the new low-cost alternative for meeting America's energy needs with domestically produced ethanol," Langley said. "E3 BioFuels' system enables America to take a giant leap from the oilfields of the Mideast to the cornfields of the Midwest. The future is now, the future is here -- with the opening of the E3 BioFuels-Mead's Genesis plant."

    "The Genesis plant effectively serves as a diligent steward of the environment -- producing a clean-burning motor fuel, solving water run-off pollution from agricultural wastes, and reducing greenhouse gas emissions," added Langley.

    Langley said E3 BioFuels plans to build 15 more such plants near feedlots and dairy farms, of increasing size, within the next five years.


    For more on E3's plant, check out Robert Rapier's excellent posts on E3 over at R-Squared blog: here and here.

    I agree wholeheartedly that this kind of 'integrated' approach to bioenergy facilities is exactly what we need to see (here's another example of this kind of integrated biorefinery). This particular configuration may not be the most sustainable, but it's far better than conventional ethanol plants, and the kind of thinking involved in planning a facility like this is exactly the kind that designers of industrial facilities should be doing.

    Industrial facilities should be planned, whenever possible, like a sort of industrial ecosystem, where each part of the facility can utilize some or all of the waste-stream (be it solid waste, used water, co-products, waste heat or steam, even carbon dioxide, etc.) from the other parts of the facility. In this way, a number of loops are closed, or at least a number of outputs are recycled into useful inputs instead of heading straight to landfills, toxic waste dumps, wastewater facilties, or our rivers, oceans and atmosphere.

    Bioenergy facilities in particular can benefit from this kind of 'industrial ecosystem' design as they often have a number of different outputs, co-products and inputs that can work well together.

    [By the way, E3's use of the descriptor, 'closed loop', is kind of misleading here, as the facility does accept corn as an input , and that corn is not grown on site (i.e., it comes from outside the facility's 'loop'). Still, this facility does close a number of other 'loops', which is laudable.]

    One proposal I've advocated for before is an integrated bioenergy facility that produced both corn and cellulose-based ethanol. The facility would accept corn and corn-stover as inputs. The corn-stover would feed a gasification-based cellulosic ethanol process (like the one BRI is developing) which would produce both ethanol and quite a bit of waste heat. Some or all of the waste heat could then go towards process heat/steam for the corn ethanol side of the facility (with the remainder generating electricity for internal use and maybe some for export if there's any left).

    This would eliminate the need for coal or natural gas to run the corn ethanol facility. The distillers' grains and solubles and other co-products produced by the ethanol process could also be fed into the cellulosic ethanol process and gasified if that was more economical than selling the co-products.

    Further expanding on this idea, based on E3's model, the facility could also incorporate an animal feed operation, using the wet distiller's grains and corn meal produced by the corn ethanol process. The manure from the animal feed operation could provide further process heat/steam/electricity for the ethanol facilities.

    Burning the methane and gasifying the corn stover (and/or other cellulosic feedstocks) also produce a CO2 waste stream (although both processes are net carbon neutral, in the case of the gasification, or negative, in the case of the methane). This CO2 could be fed to algae bioreactors like the ones being developed by GreenFuels Tech. Corp. The algae can be used as either animal feed, or to make biodiesel in a co-located biodiesel facility. The wastewater from the algae process can be used to make process steam.

    So, in this facility, you take corn and corn-stover, plus animals as inputs and end up with ethanol, meat, corn co-products, biodiesel (perhaps) and maybe some electricity [the flow diagram would look something like the tangled rats nest below]. The facility would have limited emissions, be carbon neutral or negative, should limit water use (relative to non-integrated facilities) and minimizes waste streams.

    [Graphic: A possible integrated biorefinery concept producing ethanol, electricity, biodiesel and meat from corn and corn stover inputs]

    Obviously, I'm not sure quite how the mass/energy flows would break down (you might need some more inputs, like animal feed for the animal feedlot, and there are waste streams I haven't captured here), but I think a facility like this would be possible. Expense is also clearly an issue, although I would imagine that co-locating these facilities would limit capital expenses relative to the same facilities that weren't co-located, and thus offer a competitive advantage. Still it's going to probably be more spendy than a non-integrated ethanol facility using coal for energy. Operating costs should be lower though as the integrated facility makes good use of several materials streams that what would otherwise simply be waste.

    Whatever the final product looks like, the kind of integrated 'industrial ecosystem' thinking applied by E3 Biofuels to their new ethanol facility is an excellent model of the kind of thinking that should be applied across the industrial sector. Significant energy, materials, and cost savings can be realized while reducing waste streams, pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.

    Read more!

    Wednesday, November 01, 2006

    Arizona Commission Votes to Expand Renewable Energy Standard to 15% by 2025

    Solar and other distributed generation to meet 30% of target

    RenewableEnergyAccess.com reports that the Arizona Corporation Commission (ACC) voted 4-1 on October 31 to expand the state's renewable energy standard to 15% by 2025, with 30% of that to come from distributed generation technologies - potentially resulting in up to 2,000 megawatts of solar.

    The historic vote puts Arizona in the running to become the one of the largest solar programs in the country, right behind California and potentially ahead of New Jersey. The vote also represents a major expansion of the state's renewable energy target from just 1.1 percent in 2007 to 15 percent by 2025.

    The benchmarks for renewable energy production for the state's regulated utilities accelerates over time with interim targets set at 2.5 percent of the total by 2010 to 5 percent by 2015, 10 percent by 2020 and 15 percent by 2025. The portion of that the benchmarks that must be met by distributed generation has been mapped out only through 2011. It would require distributed generation technologies meet 5 percent of each utility's Renewable Energy Standard obligation by next year and there would be 5 percent annual jumps through 2011 until the 30 percent target is reached.

    "With world-class sunshine and explosive population growth, Arizona is well positioned to become a key solar market. The game's not over yet, however. It takes more than incentives to make a sustainable solar market. The state has no regulations for interconnection standards, nor net metering. The financial incentives are the engine for solar's development -- but these policies are the road... now is the time to celebrate," stated Adam Browning, director of the Vote Solar Initiative, in an e-mail announcing the results of the October 31 vote.

    Funding for the Renewable Energy Standard will be provided through a tariff assessment of $0.004988 per kilowatt-hour (kWh) with monthly impacts capped at $1.05 for residential customers, $39 for small commercial, and $117 for large commercial. The new standard also allows for new and emerging technologies to be added as they become feasible.

    The ACC's vote yesterday marked the end of a two-year campaign to revise and expand Arizona's existing Environmental Portfolio Standard, which required just 1.1 percent of electricity sold in the state to come from renewables.

    Resources:

  • Draft Rules for Expanded Renewable Energy Standard and Tarrif - (These are draft rules from March, 2006. I couldn't find the current rules, but these look to be very close to the rules adopted by the ACC yesterday)


  • [A hat tip to Democratic Energy and RenewableEnergyAccess.com]

    Read more!

    Eye On China: China Speeds Up Renewable Energy Development

    [This article, by Jianxiang Yang of ChinaWatch, is from RenewableEnergyAccess.com.

    A lot of the material has been covered in previous 'Eye on China' posts here at WattHead, including this one earlier this month, but this long article has more detail and is worth reading for all of you interested in 'keeping an eye on China':]

    Statistics show that in 2005, a total of US$38 billion was invested in renewable energy development worldwide. China topped the list with a commitment of US$6 billion, excluding spending on large hydropower projects.

    China has good reason to speed up its renewables development, as the country is fairly poor in many energy resources in per capita terms. Its remaining exploitable reserves of petroleum and natural gas are merely 7.7 percent and 7.1 percent of world averages, while those of coal are 58.6 percent of the world average. At the current rate of extraction, China's proven reserves of these resources could last 15, 30, and 80 years, respectively, compared with world averages of 45, 61, and 230 years.

    At a Sino-European economic summit held September 12, 2006, in Hamburg, Germany, Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao assured the world that China would rely mainly on domestic supplies to meet energy needs. The government's energy policy would aim to integrate development and conservation, giving priority to the latter. China could definitely find a "new path" for sustainable development, the Premier said.

    This new path would have to include energy from renewable resources, in which China is abundant. Two-thirds of its hydropower potential is untapped. Exploitation of wind, solar, and biomass energies has just started. Although renewable energy may not yet be ready for prime time, it is expected to deliver sooner or later.

    Already, the pace of adoption is noticeable. China's renewable energy development has grown at an annual average of 25 percent over the past few years, according to Zhang Guobao, deputy director of the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC). By the end of 2005, the country's installed hydropower capacity reached 110 million kilowatts (kW), compared with 1 million kW in 2004 and only 0.492 million kW in 2000. China's 61 wind-power plants claimed a total generating capacity of 1.26 million kW in 2005, up from 0.764 million kW the year before. The 1,500 or so biogas projects resulted in a combined annual capacity of 1.5 billion cubic meters. In addition, 70,000 kW of solar power facilities were operational nationwide in 2005.

    Compared with China's total capacity of 508 million kW for all forms of energy, however, the overall shares of renewables (24.3 percent for hydropower, 0.5 percent for wind, and even smaller amounts for others) remain limited. This means enormous room for development. An incomplete list of exploitable renewable energy reserves puts the country's hydropower potential at 400 million kW, wind at around 3 billion kW, biomass energy at 800--1,000 million tons of coal equivalent a year, and solar energy at a theoretical 1.7 trillion tons of coal equivalent a year.

    Premier Wen Jiabao has urged all relevant government departments to take effective measures to accelerate the development of renewable energy, so as to "raise the share of quality, clean energies in the total energy mix."

    According to the State Renewable Energy Medium- and Long-Term Development Program, renewable energy is expected to account for 16 percent of China's total energy supply by 2020, up from 7 percent in 2005. In terms of capacity, hydropower is expected to reach 300 million kW, wind power and biomass energy 30 million kW each, and solar energy 1.8 million kW by 2020. Biogas utilization would reach 44.3 billion cubic meters, solar heating 300 million cubic meters, fuel ethanol 10 million tons a year, and biodiesel 2 million tons a year.

    China's renewable energy development is guaranteed under the nation's first Renewable Energy Law, which came into force on January 1 of this year. In February, the government issued a set of rules to implement the law. In addition, officials have decided to raise the rate for electricity consumption by 0.025 yuan per kilowatt-hour ($0.32 cents/kWh), a small fraction of which (0.001yuan/kWh, or $0.013 cents/kWh) is being collected for the development of renewable energy. And in early October, the Ministry of Finance released details of a new fund dedicated to the development of renewable energy sources, which will use grants and interest subsidies to give government support to renewables' development in three main areas: oil alternatives, construction, and power generation.

    In general, local government officials are enthusiastic about promoting renewable energy projects. Their motives vary from securing a lucrative source of government tax revenues, to building up a "green" government image, to adding a "bright spot" to their work performance records. Factors such as the embrace of new energy technologies now bear considerable weight in an official's promotion.

    Jiangsu Province in eastern China is particularly active in the renewable energy game. The prosperous region appears determined to take the lead in wind power exploitation. In less than five years, it plans to boost its wind capacity from virtually zero to 1,500 megawatts (MW). The region is also an important base for the solar industry, where more than 180 companies are involved in the development, manufacturing, and servicing of solar heating appliances.

    Earlier this year, Shanghai, China's leading industrial and financial city, announced a plan to build up 100 MW of offshore wind energy capacity. The metropolis hopes to raise the share of renewables in its total energy capacity to 5 percent by 2010. The capital city of Beijing, meanwhile, in its newly released infrastructure construction plan, has vowed to lift renewables' share in its total energy consumption from the present 1 percent to 4 percent by 2010.

    Companies across China -- whether state-owned or private, domestic or foreign-funded -- are eager to embrace renewable energy projects. Many believe the sector will soon be a gold mine, if it is not already. For some companies, particularly state-owned enterprises, the government's strong support for renewables is an inspiration. At a number of public occasions this year, NDRC deputy director Zhang Guobao noted that big energy developers in the country would ultimately be expected to derive a certain proportion of their products from renewable sources.

    Earlier this year, Longyuan Electric Power, the biggest wind player in China, announced a plan to raise its wind-power generating capacity from an existing 416 MW to 3,000 MW by 2010, and to 7,000 MW by 2020. Other major energy developers like Huaneng, Guodian, and the Three Gorges Corporation have set up subsidiary companies dedicated to new or renewable energy development.

    Foreign companies have been active as well. The world's leading wind equipment suppliers -- Vestas, GE Energy, Gamesa, and Suzlon -- have each set up wholly owned manufacturing facilities in China. And seven foreign development banks, including the International Finance Corporation, Germany's DEG, and France's Proparco, have invested in China's renewable energy projects.

    The 30,000 MW wind-power goal for 2020 represents a market of 210 billion yuan (US $26.6 billion), and the country's combined renewables targets amount to US$100 billion. The coming years are likely to witness rapid development of these energy sources, and the targets might even be reached ahead of schedule, industry analysts say.

    Yet several major barriers are preventing more rapid development of renewable energy in China. One is the weakness the country has shown in independent technology development. To date, most of the renewables' equipment being used -- whether for wind power, biomass, or solar -- has been imported, resulting in higher production and consumption costs. The Outline of National Medium- and Long-Term (2006-2020) Program for Scientific and Technological Development, released by the government in February, designates energy as the top area needing "urgent S&T support." The document lists a host of government-supported plans covering key fields of study, cutting-edge technologies, and special large programs, as well as basic research.

    China is one of 48 countries worldwide that have enacted laws for renewable energy development. But industries have given only a cautious welcome to the country's laws and accompanying rules of implementation. For many, the wording of the rules is too general to be practical. And some measures remain controversial. For instance, new regulations for wind power decree that the grid feed-in tariffs be decided through a tendering process. The measure has been criticized by industry players who fear the practice will result in price cuts and thus deny companies a reasonable profit.

    Human resources are another problem. According to experts, China aims to engage hundreds of thousands of people in wind power exploitation by 2020. The number of specialized workers alone would be in the tens of thousands. But China currently has a very meager supply of wind energy experts. Only one of the country's more than 1,000 institutions of higher learning provides a four-year program dedicated to wind energy. The situation for other renewables is not much better. Solving this problem will require the joint efforts of many government departments and social institutions, experts say.

    While the shortage of conventional energy resources is the main driver behind China's push for renewable energy, the country is also making the transition out of environment concern. The nation's coal-dominated energy system has caused severe pollution in many regions, which has compelled the government to turn to cleaner energy resources. Meanwhile, China has pledged to stage a "green" Olympics in 2008, and the environmentally friendly games are expected to be a showcase for the nation's embrace of renewable energy.

    Jianxiang Yang is a senior journalist on energy with China Features. This article was coordinated through the Global Environmental Institute (GEI) in Beijing.

    Resources:

  • ChinaWatch from Worldwatch Institute

  • National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC)

  • Great Wall World Renewable Energy Forum (GWREF)

  • ACORE: Compact Signed to Raise Renewable Energy to 25% of Global Energy Supply (Oct. 25, 2006)

  • Read more!