Energy Collective blog power policy climate - the conversation happens here

Monday, June 15, 2009

Breakthrough Generation Launches 2009 Fellowship Program


Last week, eight young leaders and intellectuals from around the country arrived at the Breakthrough Institute for the 2009 Breakthrough Generation Fellowship. Breakthrough Generation is the young leaders initiative of the Breakthrough Institute, a public policy think tank, and this summer represents our second annual fellowship program.

Selected from a large pool of applicants from the world’s top universities, this year’s fellows will continue Breakthrough Generation’s efforts to empower progressive young leaders to advance bold ideas for a stronger, safer, and more prosperous world. I invite you to follow their writing and join the discussion at the Breakthrough Generation website:

Follow Breakthrough Generation’s writing and ideas

Our 10-week fellowship includes a two-week introductory program, including a graduate-level reading course, daily blogging, and presentations from some of the country’s top energy and economic experts (reading syllabus is available for PDF download here). After this introduction, the fellows will perform research and writing throughout the summer to develop and advance the Breakthrough Institute’s efforts on energy, climate, and economic policy.

Learn more about Breakthrough Generation below the fold...

Breakthrough Generation was founded in 2007 on the premise that America’s youth are faced with an unprecedented opportunity to define a new politics for a new age. A new “post-boomer” politics is emerging today, and while its shape has yet to be determined, young people are already taking the lead. Young adults defined the course of the 2008 elections, and the youth energy movement has become the largest student movement in decades. How young people seize this opportunity can change the course of the nation -- and the world -- for years to come.

Last summer, the 2008 Breakthrough Generation Fellows had an idea to help seize this opportunity: why don't we propose a National Energy Education Act, modeled after the post-war National Defense Education Act, to create the next generation of scientists and engineers to achieve the technology breakthroughs necessary for overcoming the climate challenge?

They wrote a policy white paper. They published op-eds. And, working their connections, they made their pitch to the presidential candidates. Months later, in April 2009, President Obama announced he was launching exactly such a program – re-branded "RE-ENERGYSE” (REgaining our ENERGY Science and Engineering Edge) – with $115 million in funding for 2010.

What will come from the 2009 Breakthrough Generation Fellowship? Only time will tell, but Breakthrough Generation is committed to empowering these and other progressive young leaders to develop and advance bold ideas for change. I hope you’ll join the discussion at the Breakthrough Generation website, and if you’re a rising young leader, I hope you apply for our 2010 summer fellowship. Stay tuned!

Read more!

Sunday, June 14, 2009

CBO: Waxman-Markey to Reduce Cumulative Emissions Just 2% Between 2012-2020

By Michael Shellenberger and Jesse Jenkins. Originally posted at the Breakthrough Institute

[Updated with correction, 6/18/09: Thanks to John Larson at WRI for alerting us to an error in our data. Our data is now corrected and impacted figures and conclusions have been bolded in the text below so readers can see what has changed. An updated spreadsheet has been uploaded.

In summary: a smaller portion of economy-wide emissions were included in the emissions profile for sectors that fall under the cap starting in 2012 and a larger portion was included in the sectors that are phased into the cap starting in 2014. The result is slightly lower emissions under the ACES target scenario and CBO projected offsets scenario for the years 2012 and 2013 and slightly lower cumulative emissions between 2012-2020.

This effects the post's key result: assuming offsets are utilized at CBO's projected levels, cumulative emissions from 2012-2020 are 2.0% below BAU levels , not 0.5% as originally posted. This change has no effect on other years, on the difference between emissions at the CBO projected offsets scenario and emissions at the ACES target scenario, or on the BAU scenario. As always, we will continue to publish all of our assumptions and calculations and invite readers to look at the data and our analysis themselves. - Jesse Jenkins, Director of Energy and Climate Policy]

The Waxman-Markey climate bill (HR 2454 or the American Clean Energy and Security Act) would reduce cumulative emissions by just 2% between 2012 and 2020 in the sectors of the U.S. economy regulated under the bill's cap and trade program, according to the Congressional Budget Office's analysis of the legislation.

CBO, directed by Doug Elmendorf (pictured left), has published the first predictions from a government agency about the actual impact on U.S. emissions likely to result from the version of the Waxman-Markey legislation passed by the Energy and Commerce Committee and now heading towards debate on the House floor.

CBO's analysis confirms earlier analysis by the Breakthrough Institute that revealed the climate legislation would only establish a non-binding emissions target, not a binding cap on emissions in covered sectors. Whereas Breakthrough's analysis examined the total emissions legally permitted under the legislation (without projecting likely scenarios), CBO's new analysis utilizes economic models to project what the legislation would actually accomplish under a likely set of assumptions.

The reason CBO projects that Waxman-Markey will result in such a low and arguably immeasurable reduction in emissions in supposedly capped sectors of the U.S. economy is because their models predict most regulated firms will purchase emissions offsets rather than reduce their own emissions. The legislation legally permits regulated firms to purchase up to two billion tons of offsets each year in lieu of reducing their own emissions.

CBO projects that firms regulated under Waxman-Markey's cap and trade program would utilize 230 million tons of domestic offsets and 190 million tons of international offsets in 2012 [p. 16]. By 2020, CBO projects firms will be utilizing 300 million tons of offsets from domestic sources and 425 million tons from international sources, for a total of 725 million tons of offsets [p. 16]. That's enough to offset 61% of the emissions reductions required by the ACES cap-and-trade program in 2020.

CBO_Annual_Capped_Sectors_2009_2020.jpg
However, CBO also projects firms will purchase more offsets and emissions allowances than they need to cover their emissions in the early years of the program [p. 15]. This is because emissions permits (allowances and offsets) can be banked indefinitely under the legislation, and CBO predicts firms will purchase relatively cheap permits at the outset of the program, banking them to allow greater emissions in future years. For this reason, only an examination of cumulative emissions permitted by the legislation tells the full story of emissions reductions actually driven by the Waxman-Markey bill.

After taking into account the banking of emissions permits, Breakthrough's calculations [.xslx] reveal that if offsets are utilized at the levels projected by the CBO, Waxman-Markey will cut cumulative emissions in supposedly capped sectors of the economy by just 2% through 2020. CBO projects cumulative 2012-2020 emissions in capped sectors would be 54.5 billion metric tons, compared to cumulative emissions of 55.4 billion metric tons under the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's business-as-usual emissions projections. If offsets are utilized at CBO's projected levels, cumulative emissions in capped sectors would be over 5 billion metric tons higher than if cumulative emissions were required to fall at the ACES target emissions trajectory (e.g. 17% below 2005 by 2020).

For comparison, if the United States was on track to reduce emissions at levels consistent with IPCC recommendations for developed nations (e.g. at least 25% below 1990 levels by 2020 on a 450 ppm stabilization track), cumulative 2012-2020 emissions would be just 43.7 billion metric tons, 20% below cumulative emissions under CBO's projections for offsets.

CBO_Cumulative_Covered_Sectors.jpg
CBO predicts that cumulative economy-wide U.S. emissions between 2012 and 2020 would be reduced 5% under Waxman-Markey -- from 65.6 billion metric tons under the EPA's BAU baseline to 62.3 billion metric tons at CBO's projected offset levels. This analysis assumes that all domestic carbon offsets are emissions reductions that would not have occurred otherwise (i.e. 100% of domestic offsets are truly "additional").

CBO_Cumulative_Economy_Wide.jpg
It is worth noting that CBO's projections (like all forecasts) are based on various assumptions including the price of domestic emissions reductions, offsets, and the likely behavior of individual firms. The Waxman-Markey legislation itself does not legally require any emissions reductions below the EPA's projected emissions baseline through 2030, if offsets are available and purchased at the maximum levels permitted by the legislation.


Update, 6/15/09: An astute reader noted that CBO projects that 2 billion tons of excess emissions permits from 2012-2019 [see p. 16]. These permits are not noted in the graphics above because they will be banked and "cashed in" in future years to increase the legally-permitted emissions. For that reason, they aren't truly equivalent to real emissions reductions driven in the period examined above (2012-2020), since these emissions reductions only come at the expense of increased emissions at some later date.

However, there is something to be said for early emissions reductions, since the increased demand for early domestic emissions abatement opportunities may spur accelerated clean energy technology deployment and improvement. The following graphic therefore notes the impact of banked emissions permits on cumulative emissions from 2012-2020, based again on CBO's projections. Actual cumulative emissions in that period will be 52.5 billion metric tons, 5% lower than the 55.4 billion tons of cumulative emissions under the EPA's projected baseline. 2 billion tons of permits will be banked, allowing increased emissions in some future year after 2020.

For comparison, cumulative emissions would be cut 11% below the EPA's baseline if emissions followed the Waxman-Markey bill's target emissions trajectory (i.e. an actual cut of 17% below 2005 levels by 2020).

CBO_Cumulative_Covered_Sectors_Banking.jpg

See also: "EPA Analysis Projects Waxman Markey Would Not Require Emissions Reductions Through 2020"


===========
See Breakthrough Institute's ongoing series of original analysis of Waxman-Markey ACES climate bill collected here

Read more!

New UCS Analysis Finds Waxman-Markey RES Won't Increase Clean Energy Deployment

By Michael Shellenberger. Originally posted at the Breakthough Institute

According to a new analysis by the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS), the combined efficiency and renewable electricity standard (CERES -- formerly RES) in the Waxman-Markey climate legislation will not increase renewable electricity generation and might actually reduce it.

UCS concludes:

"Bottom line: The Waxman-Markey RES does not ensure that any new renewable electricity will be developed beyond the renewables that are already projected to occur under the business as usual forecast by the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)."

UCS created a high-deployment and a low-deployment scenario to predict the impact of the CERES provision in Waxman-Markey, as compared to the EIA's business-as-usual (BAU) baseline projections of renewable electricity generation. Under the high-deployment scenario, the Waxman-Markey CERES provision "would lead to slightly more renewable energy to be developed than business as usual" -- but only starting in 2020.


UCS Analysis of RES - Scenarios.jpg
[Download the graphic and scenario descriptions here.]

Strikingly, in the low-deployment scenario, USC found that that CERES would actually result in less and declining renewables deployment (8.3% of sales in 2020 down to 7.3% in 2030) than under the EIA baseline (9.9% in 2020 rising to 11% in 2030). UCS concludes that, under Waxman Markey, the low-deployment scenario is the more probable scenario.

"In UCS' view, the amount is likely to be closer to the low renewable energy case, because of the economic incentives to use more energy efficiency and sell renewable energy credits, and because the W-M bill provides substantial economic incentives to build new CCS and nuclear facilities. The high case, in particular, is very implausible."

The UCS analysis is consonant with RES analyses by Breakthrough Institute, the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (pdf), and the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy (SACE).

Read more!

Saturday, June 06, 2009

Graph of the Day, June 5th, 2009

Gas and oil prices on the rise again.


As I wrote back in April, a new oil shock is poised to hit the economy as soon as it begins to recover. Is this the first signs that $3 or $4/gallon gas is on it's way back?

Graph via Tim Haab at the Energy Collective

Read more!

Smart Provisions in Climate Bill Could Spur Clean Technology - If They Are Funded

Originally posted at the Breakthrough Institute

As Breakthrough's analysis of the Waxman-Markey American Clean Energy and Security Act (ACES) has revealed, the climate bill will effectively establish a non-binding "cap" on U.S. emissions while generating a pretty modest price for CO2 pollution. The implication: we can't count on the "cap" and trade provision alone -- nor the now ineffective renewable electricity standard -- to drive deep cuts in U.S. emissions or adequately accelerate clean energy deployment.

To maximize the chances that the emissions reductions aimed for by the bill -- i.e. 17 percent below 2005 levels by 2020 -- are actually achieved, Congress must adopt a proactive set of policies and public investments to accelerate clean energy technology development and deployment and supplement the bill's weakened regulations and price signals.

Several of the bill's provisions aim to do that, but we conclude that most are currently either completely unfunded or critically underfunded. Here we take a look at three smart provisions in the ACES bill that could be key components of a proactive clean energy technology strategy -- but only if they are adequately funded.

  1. Clean Energy Deployment Administration: this provision would establish a sort of public clean energy bank charged with creating an attractive investment environment for the widespread deployment of a suite of advanced clean energy technologies. Notable for being a deployment policy explicitly dedicated to advancing technology development goals, this provision also enjoys strong bipartisan support on both the House and Senate. However, ACES provides zero funding for this critical component of a proactive clean energy technology strategy. At least $16 billion in initial seed funding should be provided for CEDA, consistent with the Senate version of this provision.

  2. Energy Innovation Institutes: largely consistent with the recommendations of the Brookings Institution, Breakthrough Institute, Third Way and others, ACES establishes new "Clean Energy Innovation Centers" at research universities, national labs and private research facilities, creating new cross-sector and multi-disciplinary hubs for applied research and development on clean energy technologies. However, these energy innovation institutes are critically underfunded, receiving less than $1 billion/year in funding from the bill's cap and trade allowance value. To bring federal energy R&D programs to a scale sufficient to address the urgent energy innovation imperative and address the needs of a $1.5 trillion annual industry, at least $15 billion in new annual funding should be dedicated to energy R&D, with a significant portion of this new funding dedicated to establishing a robust nationwide network of energy innovation institutes.

  3. Carbon Capture and Sequestration Demonstration and Early Deployment Program: financed by a micro-carbon fee on all electricity sold in the United States, this program would dedicate $10 billion over the next ten years to promote the commercialization and large-scale demonstration of carbon capture and sequestration technologies for coal plants and other major point-source emitters of CO2. This program is a good example of the kind of direct public investment necessary to bring down capital and technology risk barriers and accelerate clean technology commercialization. But a much better-funded and technology neutral program that would provide competitively awarded funding for the demonstration of a whole suite of first-of-their-kind clean energy technologies is needed, and would be vastly superior to this technology-specific, industry-managed program.

We delve into each of these programs in more detail after the break...

Clean Energy Deployment Administration: added as an amendment overwhelmingly adopted on a 51-6 bipartisan vote during markup, this provision establishes a sort of public clean energy bank to finance and accelerate clean energy technology commercialization and deployment.

Sponsored by Representatives John Dingell of Michigan, Jay Inslee of Washington and Bart Gordon of Tennessee, the provision establishes a new Clean Energy Deployment Administration (CEDA) that will be responsible for creating an attractive investment environment that will spur the widespread deployment of advanced clean energy technologies, including higher risk "breakthrough technologies." The Administration would also support the widespread deployment of critical enabling infrastructure technologies (like new grid technologies), energy efficiency technologies and advanced clean energy manufacturing technologies.

Intended to be a self-sustaining revolving fund, CEDA will leverage federal funds to provide direct loans, loan guarantees, letters of credit, insurance products and other credit enhancement mechanisms to support clean energy technology commercialization and deployment. Funds generated by the repayment of these loans and credit enhancement products will be returned to the CEDA fund to be redeployed.

The new administration would be staffed by professionals experienced in project financing and technology commercialization and would manage a portfolio of projects with various levels of technology risk. This portfolio approach will allow CEDA to maximize the support provided for "breakthrough technologies" -- defined by the bill as clean energy technologies that have a high potential to advance American energy objectives but are not yet "considered a commercially ready technology due to high perceived technology risk or similar factors." In this way, CEDA is designed to provide the patient capital that can help emerging clean energy technologies bridge the infamous technology "Valley of Death" -- the window between R&D and commercialization that many potentially high-impact but high-risk technologies succumb to for lack of financing. Venture capitalists generally look to cash out their investments in 3-5 years, and many technologies struggle to prove themselves in this time frame without the kind of patient capital financing CEDA could provide.

This Clean Energy Deployment Authority provision is notable for two reasons:

First, it was one of just two amendments passed during the marathon four-day Energy and Commerce Committee markup to receive broad bipartisan support from nearly the entire committee, again indicating the widespread support for clean technology development measures.

Second, while the bill is dedicated to spurring the commercial deployment of clean energy, it explicitly views these activities as part of the broader technology development process and includes specific technology development and price improvement objectives in it's operating mission. Technology development doesn't stop at the edge of the lab, and it's high time Congress established a series of clean energy deployment and development policies that were designed as part of a proactive and coordinated portfolio of clean technology development policies aimed at supporting the entire clean energy technology pipeline. This CEDA provision is a smart step in the right direction.

Unfortunately, the Waxman-Markey bill provides NO funding for this critical and potentially high-impact new Clean Energy Deployment Administration. Despite divvying up roughly $1 trillion in allowance value from the bill's cap and trade program between 2012 and 2025 alone (most of which is used to blunt the carbon prices' already modest impact on polluting industries and consumers), the ACES bill dedicates none of this revenue to seed CEDA's clean energy investment fund. Instead, the provision authorizes "such sums as are necessary" to be appropriated at some later date, effectively kicking this critical clean technology program into the tumultuous budget appropriations process to find funding somewhere else.

In contrast, a Senate version of this provision included the energy bill now being marked up in the Energy and Natural Resources Committee, dedicates billions in funding to launch this new program. Like the ACES bill's CEDA amendment, the Senate's "21st Century Energy Technology Deployment Act" has strong bipartisan support and is sponsored by Democratic Senators Bingaman, Dorgan, Stabenow and Shaheen and Republicans Murkowski, Voinovich and Lugar.

Most importantly, the Senate version dedicates $10 billion to set up the CEDA fund and specifies that the roughly $6.25 billion already appropriated for the Department of Energy's troubled loan guarantee programs will be managed by CEDA instead, providing $16.25 billion in start-up funding to kick-start the revolving financing program.

CEDA would be able to leverage this initial funding considerably. Loan guarantees are regularly leveraged at 10 to 1 or more, meaning this level of initial funding would help spur private investment in clean energy technology projects worth more than $160 billion -- and that's before the fund revolves even once -- a clearly high-impact use of federal dollars.

If Congress is serious about spurring clean technology development and strengthening the ACES bill, the Clean Energy Deployment Administration should receive at least $16 billion in starting funding, as in the Senate version of the legislation. CEDA could put this funding -- and probably much more -- to very effective use, driving the deployment of advanced clean energy technologies, strengthening American technological and economic competitiveness and helping achieve needed emissions reductions.


Energy Innovation Institutes: one percent of the ACES bill's cap and trade allowances will be allocated to finance "Clean Energy Innovation Centers" at research universities, national labs and private research facilities, creating new cross-sector and multi-disciplinary hubs for applied research and development on clean energy technologies.

These new energy innovation hubs are largely consistent with the new paradigm for federal energy innovation advocated by the Breakthrough Institute and Third Way in a forthcoming report due out this month and by Breakthrough and the Brookings Institution in a recent column at Yale e360. As we wrote with Brookings (who's Metropolitan Policy Project team has done yeoman's work developing this concept to date), in order to spur a clean energy technology revolution and make clean energy cheap, "federal and state governments, universities, and the private sector must join together to create a network of energy research institutes that could speed development of everything from advanced batteries to biofuels."

However, as much as we are excited to see this new model for energy innovation included in the American Clean Energy and Security Act, we are equally disappointed by the level of funding provided for this critical clean energy R&D program.


Overall federal clean energy R&D funding overall should be raised to $20 billion annually (from around $5 billion today) to bring it to the scale necessary to have a real impact on the $1.5 trillion U.S. energy and transportation industries and provide a level of funding comparable to other national innovation priorities (e.g. health and defense R&D) and historic innovation projects (e.g. inventing the atomic bomb and putting a man on the moon). A significant portion of this new funding would be necessary to establish a robust nationwide network of energy innovation institutes.

In contrast, the ACES bill provides less than $1 billion annually in new funding for clean energy R&D leaving funding for both these new institutes and overall federal R&D budgets inadequate to the meet the energy innovation imperative we face. To adequately spur clean energy innovation and prime the clean technology pipeline, ACES should provide at least $15 billion annually in new clean energy R&D funding, with a sizable portion of this new funding dedicated to establishing new energy innovation institutes.


Carbon Capture and Sequestration Demonstration and Early Deployment Program: added to the bill at the request of influential Energy and Commerce Committee member Representative Rick Boucher (D-VA), this provision dedicates $10 billion in funding over the next ten years to help spur the large-scale demonstration and commercialization of carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) technology for coal plants and other major point-source emitters of CO2.

Funded by what is essentially a micro-carbon tax on all electricity consumed in the United States -- also known as a "wires fee" -- this provision would fund the establishment of a Carbon Storage Research Corporation that would be operated as a division of the electricity industry's Electric Power Research Institute. The Corporation would use this revenue to fund the large-scale demonstration of a variety of CCS capture and storage technologies in order to accelerate their commercial availability.

Funded as it is by a dedicated fee assessed on American electricity consumers -- the fee will average about 50 cents per month for the average American -- and dedicated purely to CCS research, one would be forgiven for seeing this as a pretty sweet deal for coal-reliant utilities.

At the same time though, it's a prime example of the kind of public investment and dedicated programs necessary to overcome the major capital barriers and high financial risk associated with the commercial demonstration of first-of-its kind energy technologies. The question really is: why is CCS the only technology to get this kind of deal? Why no program to spur the demonstration of advanced/engineered geothermal energy or deepwater floating offshore wind turbines?

Why not up the carbon fee to $2.00 a month and provide $4 billion annually to fund a new Clean Energy Demonstration Agency that would invest directly in the commercial demonstration of a whole portfolio of emerging clean energy technologies; or use the funding to create a division within the Clean Energy Deployment Administration to directly finance these programs, expanding the tools CEDA can use to spur clean technology commercialization?

The Carbon Capture and Sequestration Demonstration and Early Deployment Program is a good example of the kind of direct public investment necessary to bring down capital and technology risk barriers and accelerate clean technology commercialization. But a much better-funded and technology neutral program that would provide competitively awarded funding for the demonstration of a whole suite of first-of-their-kind clean energy technologies is needed, and would be vastly superior to this technology-specific, industry-managed program.

Read more!

Friday, June 05, 2009

Southern Alliance for Clean Energy Confirms: ACES Renewable Electricity Standard Will Have "Effectively Zero" Impact

With most DC-based environmental organizations at least grudgingly supporting the Waxman-Markey American Clean Energy and Security Act, and official government analysis of the latest version of the bill still pending, it has been largely up to independent think tanks, advocates and bloggers to take a critical look at the major provisions in the nearly 1,000-page climate and clean energy bill. I've spent most of the past two weeks doing just that with my team at the Breakthrough Institute, and we have released some of the first analysis of the bill's cap and trade provision, allowance allocations, and renewable electricity standard.

Yesterday, the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy (SACE), a Knoxville, Tennessee-based non-profit organization advocating clean energy solutions throughout the southeastern United States, released their own analysis of the Waxman-Markey renewable electricity standard. SACE's independent analysis confirms Breakthrough's own earlier look at the now severely-weakened renewable electricity standard, concluding as we did, that the impact of the renewable electricity standard on U.S. renewable electricity generation will be "effectively zero."

SACE also looks at the likely impact of the efficiency requirements in the now combined efficiency and renewable electricity standard (which the Alliance refers to using yet another new acronym: "CERES") and concludes it falls far short of President Obama's campaign pledge to reduce U.S. electricity consumption 15% by 2020 (below business as usual projections).

John Wilson, the Alliance's director of research, writes:

Our organization and other advocates are becoming increasingly concerned about the House Waxman-Markey energy and climate bill and its companion in the Senate for a host of reasons. Among the most dramatic changes made by the House Committee on Energy and Commerce is the "Combined Efficiency and Renewable Energy Standard," or "CERES" as people are starting to call it.

It is clear that President Obama's campaign pledge to "create millions of new green jobs" by ensuring that 25 percent of our electricity comes from renewable sources by 2025 is not being realized in this legislation. Our analysis suggests that this bill would not help America make any progress towards that goal, at least through 2020. Furthermore, this bill falls far short of President Obama's pledge "to reduce electricity demand 15 percent from projected levels by 2020."

Let's be clear, in addition to creating a healthier economy and global environment, these provisions are essential to the long-term jobs strategy that we desperately need. Prior to combining energy efficiency and renewable energy, the Waxman-Markey bill promised 297,000 new renewable energy jobs by 2025 and 222,000 new energy efficiency jobs by 2020. With more than half a million jobs at stake, the CERES compromise barely opens the hiring office. The lower energy efficiency targets may be strong enough to create 60,000 jobs. And with the renewable electricity standard almost completely gutted, it looks like all the new renewable energy jobs will be in the credit trading business.

One of the unfortunate conclusions that I draw from analysis of the CERES is that in an effort to add "flexibility" by coupling the renewable energy and energy efficiency portions of the bill, the potential impact of the bill has been diluted to the point where it would actually be better to have just a standalone energy efficiency standard than the CERES. If that were to happen, the bill would at least represent a more sure-footed path towards achieving the green jobs goal for energy efficiency.

The CERES would result in no new renewable energy development according to our analysis, which considers three basic components. First, the utility qualification threshold and various factors that diminish the effective requirements of the CERES. Second, the existing state renewable electricity standards (state RES) and existing generation. Third, the interaction with the opportunity to use energy efficiency to partially comply with the CERES.

In 2020, about 8% renewable energy will be generated simply from compliance with existing state standards and continued operation of existing renewable energy facilities. This 8% floor is derived from data assembled by Union of Concerned Scientists, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (pdf), and Energy Information Administration. Although the CERES is set at 12-15% for qualified utilities, after taking into consideration the qualification threshold and several other factors, the CERES would at most require an 1.4% increase in renewable energy above the 8% floor. However, additional exemptions that cannot be quantified (for reasons discussed below) are very likely to reduce the impact of CERES to effectively zero.

...

The CERES would mandate more energy efficiency, as much as 4-8% in 16 states and the District of Columbia. A similar number of states already have a state energy efficiency resource standard (EERS), but 17 states would remain without a substantial energy efficiency mandate. Across the Southeast, and in a few other states, the CERES mandate would lift the energy efficiency programs from insignificant levels to mid-level efforts.

The original stand-alone national EERS would have required cumulative energy savings of 15% from qualified utilities, taking into consideration building codes, etc. Because building codes accounted for about 4% of the 15%, allowing utilities to meet either 5 or 8% of the CERES standard with energy efficiency represents a reduction in the EERS of at least 3 to 6% on paper. But the same qualification threshold and other factors that diminish the renewable energy impact of the CERES also diminish the energy efficiency impact.

In 2020, the proposed CERES would drive a national reduction of 2.5% in electricity use (somewhat less, actually, due to the same unquantified exemptions mentioned above). In contrast, ACEEE data indicate that electricity use would be reduced by about 5% nationwide from the EERS obligations in 21 states. Even though the CERES would have an important impact, it is clear that a minority of states are still setting the pace on energy efficiency and that the CERES would be a least-common-denominator approach.

stateeeadditional_hires.png
A glance at the state map indicates that the CERES would have highly irregular impacts from state to state. The renewable-energy oriented qualification and exclusion factors create large differences in the effective statewide standard. (Since utilities have the opportunity to meet energy efficiency targets anywhere in their state, this is the appropriate region of analysis.)

Alaska has no energy efficiency mandate because none of its utilities qualify to be regulated under the CERES. The CERES has little or no impact on North Carolina and several other states due to the combined effects of weak state RES and EERS requirements, existing renewable energy generation, qualification limits, and other factors.

This analysis probably overstates the impact of the CERES for several reasons. Although we've got a very good idea of which utilities qualify under the CERES, the base amount against which the 20% mandate is assessed is impossible to anticipate using available data sources. The base amount is reduced by three factors: existing hydroelectric generation, new nuclear generation, and new coal generation with carbon capture and storage (CCS). Another way of looking at it is that utilities get 20% credit towards the CERES for these energy resources.

We aren't able to anticipate which utilities will have new nuclear or coal with CCS by 2020, so we don't adjust for these base amount reductions. However, 35 GW of new nuclear or coal with CCS would be enough (if strategically located) to eliminate the 1.4% renewable energy requirement. That's probably a stretch goal for 2020, but certainly some qualifying power plants will be complete by then.

Our data on existing hydroelectric generation are from the Energy Information Administration. We assume that all of this generation would be used by qualified utilities to reduce their base amount. Although a small amount of this generation probably cannot be effectively transferred from non-qualified utilities, the major problem with this assumption is that some of this generation is considered "new" and thus does not reduce the base amount. Instead, it may be used by the utility to meet its federal CERES obligation. This unknown amount of hydroelectric is effectively undercounted by 80% in our analysis. If just 10% of existing hydroelectric production is "new," then that would reduce the 1.4% renewable energy requirement to 0.9%.

Another source of under counting the utilities' existing resources to comply with the CERES is the distributed generation credit. Existing and early developers of distributed generation will receive triple credit for their projects. We assumed that solar energy projects specifically mandated in state EERS rules would receive this triple credit, but in reality there would be other qualifying energy projects. This would effectively increase the number of RECs generated as a result of compliance with state EERS deadlines. However, considering that distributed generation has been slow to take hold, this should be on the order of a 0.1-0.3% reduction.

Finally, we did not take into consideration banking (or retirement) of federal RECs. To the extent that early state RES deadlines create a surplus of federal RECs, federal RECs can be banked for three years, pushing out the date at which the CERES might actually require some renewable energy development. This could be in excess of 1% per year for several years until the backlog is cleared.

If these factors together aren't enough to erase the 1.4% renewable energy requirement, then we just have to look at the growth rates from EIA that we used and wonder if they might be a little too optimistic. If actual energy demand in 2020 is 2% lower than the forecast we developed based on the Annual Energy Outlook, then the CERES mandate would be reduced by approximately 0.4% (depending on which states have the lower growth). And since we used 2020 forecast electricity sales as our baseline (rather than 2019), we've probably overestimated the impact of the AEO2009 forecast anyway.


I'll again note that analysis from the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (pdf) of the broadly consistent 20% by 2021 Senate combined efficiency and renewable electricity standard also corroborates the conclusions reached by Breakthrough and the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy's respective analysis of the Waxman-Markey combined standard.


===========
See Breakthrough Institute's additional analysis of Waxman-Markey ACES climate bill collected here

Originally posted at the Breakthrough Institute

Read more!

Thursday, June 04, 2009

Defending Big Government - Or Why We Can't Leave Energy Innovation to Markets

Marc Gunther, the excellent Fortune magazine and GreenBiz.com writer and fellow blogger at the Energy Collective, published a piece last week skeptical of the Obama Administration's new push to support the commercialization of advanced batteries in the United States and help accelerate the day when efficient plug-in hybrid electric vehicles are rolling off American assembly lines and parked in a driveway near you. At issue is $2.4 billion in new funding made available by the U.S. Department of Energy to support advanced battery commercialization and manufacturing.

Gunther quotes a Wall Street Journal article that shares his skepticism of this new funding, which will (in their words) "annoint" new technological and corporate "winners" -- something the Journal clearly sees as an unnecessary intrusion of government on free markets. Gunther agrees, writing:

"They’ve got a point, though, don’t they? One unhappy result of all the bank bailouts of the fall is that $2.4 billion doesn’t seem like much—hey, Citi alone has collected north of $45 billion, last time I checked—but a billion here, a billion there, and you’re starting to talk real money. And if electric cars are going to be as big a business as a lot of people think, then why government investment should be needed at all? Particularly since we have a climate change bill making its way through Congress that will, at long last, if all goes well, put a price on carbon emissions—thereby giving low-carbon energy sources what they desperately need, which is a fighting chance to compete with fossil fuels on something resembling a level playing field. I thought the whole idea behind cap-and-trade (which I strongly favor) is to capture the externalized cost of global warming pollutants, and then let the market figure out how best to reduce greenhouse gas emissions: regulation that would have a light touch but a profound impact.

But no—with Waxman-Markey, CAFE standards, biofuels mandates, subsidies for “green jobs” and the like—the administration is giving us a belt and a couple of pairs of suspenders, too. Much as I admire Steven Chu, the energy secretary, do we really want to entrust him and his staff to decide which battery technologies are likely to succeed and which companies can most wisely spend that $2.4 billion?"
And as much as I respect Marc Gunther, I quickly took issue with this pretty classic set of objections to government involvement in technological development. I wrote this response, which Gunther dubbed "WattHead Defends Big Government," and was happy to post at his personal blog and at GreenBiz. It has now been syndicated at The Energy Collective and at Reuters as well. Here it is for WattHead readers:

"WattHead Defends Big Government"

I’ve spent the past two weeks digging deep into the Waxman-Markey ACES climate bill, peering beneath rocks and shining my flashlight into its dark recess to figure out what it will and will not do. You can find that analysis at the Breakthrough Institute site here, and I highly recommend you take a look so you can get an accurate picture of what this “light touch-high impact” carbon pricing policy will actually accomplish.

The short answer: not very much at all.

The carbon price the bill will implement is likely to be between $12-20 per ton for the first decade-plus, according to the EPA analysis of the bill. That’s about 12 to 20 cents per gallon of gasoline, which on the low end is about as much difference as you can find between different gas stations on two sides side of town, and on the high end is lost in the noise of seasonal variation in gas prices. If you have little faith in the power of government, then I challenge you to explain how that kind of meager price signal is going to shift private investment and dramatically transform the $1.5 trillion combined U.S. energy and transportation markets. Please, tell me a convincing story about how that might work, because after spending two weeks reading the Waxman-Markey bill, I could use some more uplifting news.

The reason the CO2 price will remain so low is because the bill allows up to 2 billion tons of offsets (up to 1.5 billion which may be sources from overseas) to be used in lieu of cutting emissions here in supposedly ‘capped’ sectors. That’s enough to legally permit U.S. emissions to continue to grow at business as usual rates through 2030. So Waxman-Markey gives us no real “cap” on carbon and no significant price on carbon. Forgive me for looking for other ways to directly spur the transformative clean energy innovation we need — ways you may consider unfortunate degrees of “government intervention.” Given what’s at stake after all…

Also, as a kind of test to consider: many European nations have had gas taxes for decades that implement an effective carbon price in the hundreds of dollars a ton range ($2-5/gallon tax = roughly $200-500 per ton of CO2 equivalent carbon price!). So with such a powerful signal for private investors to develop alternative fuel vehicles, why haven’t firms in Europe invented and commercialized electric cars? Why isn’t everyone in Denmark driving EVs, one might ask?

The answer is because that’s not really how innovation works. Price signals alone do not spur adequate innovation. There’s a multitude of market failures at work, especially in the energy innovation sphere. I have a paper coming out in about two weeks which I’ll share with my readers and the The Energy Collective community that spells out a lot of these market failures (prelude: knowledge spillovers, very high capital barriers and non-differentiated commodities are three big barriers to sufficient private sector innovation investments). These are the kinds of market failures, which when combined with clear public imperatives for change, simply demand more active government engagement with innovation and industry than we all may find ideal.

For now, I’ll again challenge the typical assertions that private entrepreneurialism and investment (and the proper price signals) are all that’s required to spur transformative innovation by pointing you to my publication, “Case Studies in American Innovation: A New Look at Government Involvement in Technological Innovation” [PDF] for examples of how active federal government engagement and investment paved the way for so many of the technologies we now take for granted, including microchips, personal computing, the Internet, commerical aviation and jet engines, gas combustion turbines, nuclear power, wind power, solar power, etc. Take a look and see why I’m not as skeptical of the role of government as you are.

Finally, as a (mostly) side note, since you cite Tesla Motors targeting luxury car markets with their electric Roadster as a reason they should not receive federal incentives: the reason Tesla is starting with a $100k electric luxury car is because new technologies are routinely more expensive at their launch. If there isn’t a market for early adopters, the technology will never reach the economies of scale and spur the learning by doing (and continued innovation) that drops the price and improves the performance of the technology over time. Think flat screen TVs or cell phones: the first ones are far more expensive than most can afford. But now these technologies have reached economies of scale that drove dramatic price reductions and the technologies are affordable and (because of that) ubiquitous.

Tesla is looking to use luxury buyers - who routinely pay more for the cool new thing - to drive those initial economies of scale. They plan to produce the Roadster on a scale of 1,000s and at a cost of $100k. Their next model will use the same (and now cheaper) components and batteries at a larger scale and will be a luxury sedan selling for around $60k and at a scale of 10s of thousands. They then plan to produce a $35-40k sedan at a scale of 100ks per year, if all goes well. That’s just smart. Please don’t use that as a reason not to incentivize their technology’s development with public investment. If the government were willing to directly purchase batteries and serve as the early adopter themselves — as we did for microchips, radios, radar, lasers, early computers, and jet engines — we could bring this emerging technology to scale and down in price much more rapidly and pave the way for the kind of dramatic private sector innovation that occurred AFTER the government purchasing (and loss-leading) dropped these technologies in price. In short: we should be seeing far more direct public investment in the technologies to enable electrified transportation, not less.

Marc, I challenge you to wrestle with the history of innovation in a real honest way, and look for the role of government engagement in these technologies. The energy innovation imperative is simply too critical to leave to well-established (but quite inaccurate) myths about the infallibility of private sector innovation and the supposed ineptitude of any government engagement in the market. If the financial crisis taught us anything, I’d hope it was that we should revisit those myths with a pretty damned critical eye, eh my friend?

Read more!

Tuesday, June 02, 2009

An Energy Smart Senator Speaks Up

This is a guest post from A. Siegel who regularly writes excellent climate and energy analysis and commentary at Get Energy Smart Now! and DailyKos

Senator Jeff Merkley (D-OR) came to the podium during today’s luncheon session at America’s Future NOW! focused on energy. He opened, reinforcing core points from his 2008 campaign:

If I’d been here a year ago, I would have talked to you about three things: The need to transform our energy economy, create jobs, and tackle global warming. … About the third, during the campaign, I spoke about it every single night. People asked me why, as it was 21st on people’s concerns. I responded: it should be first on everyone’s agenda and the only way it will be is if we talk about it.

Senator Merkley speaks, today and elsewhere, knowledgeably and forcefully about Global Warming, providing a litany of items that should be part of the agenda moving ahead. Amid these items and opportunity, Senator Merkley made some key points. But, he provided a straightforward shorthand of what must happen.

If I am going to simplify the issue, we have to quit taking geologic carbon and turning it into atmospheric carbon.

Right now, Senator Merkley is looking to the developments in the House with the Waxman-Markey American Clean Energy and Security Act. And, evidently, he isn’t very pleased by what we see. He stated that the bill must have a strong Renewable Electricity Standard (RES), a 25% by 2025 “You’re probably all aware that we don’t have that in the current bill.” [Editor's note: nope!]

In the past, people have described the Senate as the place where a good House bill goes to die. … We need to change that. We need to reestablish that the Senate is the place where an okay bill goes to get vastly improved.

Senator Merkley also emphasized that “We need a polluter’s pay strategy … we need a price to pay if you’re putting carbon dioxide in the air. Even more, we need an incentive to reduce putting carbon in the air.”

Clearly Senator Merkley is concerned, seriously concerned.

“The number that sticks in my mind is that all the problems that we are seeing around the globe come from less than a degree of warming. … If we don’t get our act together, in 50 years we could have five degrees of warming and that would be catastrophic.”

Senator Merkley sees real potential for change for the better, but fears that we won’t seize the opportunity.

"There is the possibility that we will end up with a framework that is ineffective, that has offsets, that doesn’t have a firm cap. … Or, we could end up with something that could really transform our use of energy. Obviously, we’re going to have to work real hard to get from the former to the latter."

Do Senator Merkley’s comments presage a fight to come that could result in improving the ACES Act when it comes to the Senate?

We can hope …

And, we can help by Speaking 16 times louder …

Here is the entire session.

New Energy for America at America's Future Now! from AmericasFuture on Vimeo.

Forging a strategy that brings the ideal of green energy and green-collar jobs into political and practical reality is the focus of a luncheon panel discussion with Sen. Jeff Merkley, D-Ore.; Kate Gordon, co-director of the Apollo Alliance; Carl Pope, executive director of the Sierra Club; Mark Ayers, president of the Building and Construction Trades Department of the AFL-CIO, and Phaedra Ellis-Lamkins, chief executive officer of Green For All.

New Energy for America at America’s Future Now! from AmericasFuture on Vimeo.

Note: Listening to today’s speech reminded me why I supported Energy Smart Jeff. [Editor's note: me as well! Proud to have Senator Merkley representing my old home state.]

_______________________

If you're interested in the full transcript of remarks from Senator Merkley, see below:

Senator Merkley’s Speech – New Energy for America at America’s Future Now!
Tuesday, June 2, 2009

Kate, thank you so much. It is a delight to be here.

If this is a year ago, I’d be talking to you about how we need to transform our energy economy to create jobs and to tackle global warning, and that that is why you should support me in my campaign.

Well, you all in the progressive community responded to that and supported me and supported so much others and helped create the possibility , the opportunity to open the door to an incredible year that we desperately need here in the United states of America. We need a President, and we need a Senate that can work in partnership with that President to create incredible transformational change.

And there’s a number of incredible things that have happened so far this year which have been great, such as the wilderness bill, children’s health care, pay equity, credit cards, a series of financial bridges for our working families. But the big battles of transforming Wall Street, creating affordable healthcare for every single American, and certainly the goal of transforming our energy economy and leading in global warming, these are the battles of the next five months, and your role as the progressive community is going to be critical if we are going to emerge from this year with significant changes in each of these areas.

I’m so delighted to be here to talk about the third. During the campaign, I talked about this every single night, and people would say, “Jeff, surveys show that global warming is 21st on the list of voter concerns. Why are you talking about it every single night?” I would say, first, it’s a major reason I’m running for the US Senate. And second of all, it should be first on everyone’s list, and it’s only going to get there if we talk about it.

So now we’re en route here, and there are three fundamental pieces or goals that should be a part of this energy transformation. One is ending dependence on foreign oil and national security that flows from that. The second is creating jobs, and we’re going to create a lot more jobs if we’re not spending two billion dollars a day on foreign oil and we’re spending that money here on clean energy in the United States of America. And the third, is to tackle global warming.

I know I’m talking to folks, to all of you, and you know a lot about this, but the number that is just anchored in my heart and soul is that everything we’ve seen in the world is a result of a one degree temperature change, or even less than a one degree temperature change. The retreating glaciers, the thinner ice sheets, the process of changing currents, changing weather patterns, moving insect populations, all of this, less than one degree. But if we don’t act successful now, and if we stay on this path we are on as a planet, then fifty years from now, so when a small child now is my age, I’m fifty-two, we will see a world of probably a five degree or more temperature increase. And that is catastrophic, catastrophic for our ecosystems, and catastrophic for our human civilization and it is a moral issue that we do not let this happen.

If I was to simplify a complicated issue, we have to stop taking geologic carbon and turning it into atmospheric carbon dioxide. Plenty of other pieces of the puzzle, but that is at the heart of it.

And so, among the ways we can take this on, certainly energy efficiency. Buildings - 2.2 tons of CO2 per year in North America, office buildings and residences. We can vastly increase the efficiency of the use of energy and decrease carbon dioxide produced through buildings and their consumption of electricity, which in turn is consumption of many fuel sources, carbon fuel sources.

Transportation - huge opportunity to make transportation more efficient. What would happen if, ten years from now, every car manufactured in the United States of America went its first 30 miles on electricity and had regenerative braking? Well, crudely, 80% reduction in carbon dioxide. And that’s a far more, far more vigorous effort than anything on the tailpipe issue. The modest increases in miles per gallon that we’re talking about fleet standards, that’s this big an issue. We could make a much, much larger gain through a transformation in terms of the types of propulsion that we’re using.

Next, we can bypass carbon altogether. And that is, of course, where wind, solar and wave come in. In cases where we can’t bypass carbon altogether, we can pull our carbon from a recycled process, in which we are looking to pull carbon out of the air, and when I said this in the past one person spoke up and said, “Jeff, wouldn’t it be great if we had a mechanical device or a device that would pull carbon dioxide out of the air?” Well, the great news is, we do. It’s called a tree, and we need to use those trees. We need to end deforestation and we need to be involved massively in reforestation. And in some cases we are able to take and have progressive thinning policies that are really win-win.

We have forests burning down across my home state of Oregon, which just puts everything right back into the air. But through thinning that produces lower fire risk, much lower fire risk, much lower disease risk, proceeds to leave medium age trees in places that are absorbing more carbon dioxide, and use the biomass, then there is a possibility of a real win-win there.

And then certainly, when we can’t do those mechanisms, and we’re burning carbon, capturing the carbon before it goes into the air. Now this is an area that requires a lot of research. Will it really work to sequester carbon geologically in the earth? I don’t know, jury’s out on that, but it’s worth research. Is it possible to capture carbon dioxide that’s going up the flu stack and trap it and put it into concrete? Well, there’s a firm in California that thinks the answer is yes, and they’re looking for a large scale demonstration. (Picks up piece of rock with plaque) I passed on a piece of their concrete, so this is one form of carbon sequestration, which is an interesting idea to pursue.

So those are kind of the set of issues that help frame the clean energy and jobs bill that we’re working on right now in the Senate. This bill has to have a long term commitment to the purchase of renewable non-carbon energy. And that’s why the renewable energy standard is so important. As Speaker of the house in Oregon two years ago, we established the most aggressive standard in the nation, a 25% by 2025 not including existing hydropower, and we need a 25, 2025 standard here in the United States as a whole, don’t you think?

And you are probably all aware, we don’t have that in the current draft on the House side. In the past, people have described the Senate as the place where good House bills go to die, I’m hoping that when we go through this process of working on this clean energy and jobs bill, we’ll reestablish the Senate as the place where an ok bill comes to be vastly improved in the US Senate.

Another standard that would help to drive things would be to really have an energy efficiency standard, a 15% improvement by 2020. One of the ways and one of the bills that I’m going to be introducing to tackle this is to help people with the upfront costs. When the savings outweigh the loan payments, the barrier is really that people don’t have the upfront cash. So if we have a revolving, low-interest fund in which people can see the payments on their electric bill but the savings are greater than the payments, much more likely people are going to buy those energy efficient windows, et, etc. And we want to do that as soon as possible, and increase as much investment in that area as possible.

We need a 21st century transportation system, and certainly each piece has its place. Certainly, light rail, certainly, high speed rail to replace a lot of the coastal traffic north and south on both coasts, east and west. Certainly, streetcars, and I’ve got to mention this because if anyone’s from Arizona, from Tucson, thank you very much, they have just agreed to purchase 7 streetcars from an Oregon company that is the first manufacturer of streetcars here in the United States in a generation.

And I’ve already mentioned advanced technology in transportation in cars, regenerative braking, going to electricity, of course that electricity in renewable, non carbon forms. And, what about this: What if all of our transportation project were measured, and a key part of the decision matrix for federal funding was the global warming impact? We don’t have that kind of index for federal transportation projects. I raised that question today with the Assistant Secretary for Highways, and he seemed very interested, so let’s pursue it.

And then we need a polluters pay strategy. We need a price to pay if you’re putting carbon dioxide or methane into the air, and more importantly we need an incentive to stop putting it into the air, because if you are willing to reduce those emissions then you reduce your costs.
And of course, that is a key piece of this clean energy and jobs bill, and a lot of wrinkles to be worked out yet, to make it real. And I think there is going to be the possibility that we end up with a framework that is ineffective, that has offsets, it isn’t a firm cap, the offsets aren’t real, the subsidies don’t design to suit change, or we’re going to end up with something that can really transform our use of energy and obviously we’re going to have to work really hard to get from the prior to the latter.

And finally, research, research, research. We simply need to recognize that we don’t have all the answers, and that some pathways are going to be a mistake. Corn ethanol, for example, and now we’ve committed huge national resources in this area, and it’s counterproductive. And it’s very hard to stop going down a path once that firm channel has been carved. So, we need to really study and keep working on a lot of different ideas to how we tackle this.

This revolution in energy is under way in Oregon. Last week I was at the Oregon Institute of Technology, which has just drug a super deep well, a geothermal well, its goal is to become the first campus that is completely supported, not just heating, but all electricity coming from geothermal, the first energy neutral campus.

I met with group on wave energy, the Oregon Power Technology Group, and they are working to become the first commercial wave energy project, huge potential. And they are doing such a good job right now in working with the coastal communities, so it is a win-win for those communities and not something that displaces fishing or crabbing.

Biomass, I’ve talked about a little bit, the use of sustainable thinning and wind cycle, and all of this, and I’m going to wrap it up here because I saw the card, is that one minute now?

Alright well, here’s what is comes down to: The economy and the environment are not at war. These are twins joined at the hip, each one is going to depend on the other, if we’re going to transform our economy in the world and create far more jobs, then we need and energy revolution, and certainly, if we’re going to succeed in driving an energy revolution then it has to generate jobs. So, these are partners, and we need to make sure as we go forward, that we make them work very well together. I’ll close simply by saying, that you all, the progressive community, created the opportunity for us, to transform our energy economy, now we need to work with you, we need your all’s help to seize this opportunity and actually deliver it here and make 2009 an extraordinary turning point for America in the world. Thank you very, very much.


Read more!