Compared to President Obama's promises and the recommendations of a variety of energy experts alike, the ACES climate and clean energy bill's investments in clean energy are an order of magnitude too small.
[Updated 5/22/09: the ACES bill now includes a $10/ton price floor for auctioned pollution permits. The analysis below has been updated to reflect that change in the legislation]
Today, the House Energy and Commerce Committee began markup of the American Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009 (ACES). The bill promises to cap and reduce carbon pollution, create clean energy jobs, and spur technology innovation. Unfortunately, as our analysis of the use of carbon pollution allowances in the ACES bill revealed, the bill is on course to invest very little of the hundreds of billions of dollars in value created by the bill's cap-and-trade program over the coming years towards those objectives.
Most of the allowance value (74 percent) created by the ACES cap and trade program is dedicated to blunting the impact of the carbon price established by the program on industries and consumers (and securing the critical swing votes on the committee representing these entrenched energy and industry interests). In contrast, just 12 percent of the allowance value is dedicated to clean energy investments, broadly defined.
At an average allowance price of $10 to $20 dollars per ton of CO2 between 2012-2025, that would amount to clean energy investments of just $6-12 billion per year, and just $490-980 million for clean energy R&D (see our full analysis of the allowance allocations in ACES for more).
President Obama has repeatedly promised to, "Invest $150 billion over ten years in energy research and development to transition to a clean energy economy" (from WhiteHouse.gov). The President's 2010 Budget Outline specifically dedicated $15 billion per year in new revenue generated by a cap and trade program to this purpose. Yet the bill before us, depending on the allowance value it establishes, would invest just one-fifteenth to one-thirtieth of the $15 billion President Obama has pledged -- and specifically requested from Congress. Furthermore, this new energy R&D spending may amount to just a ten percent increase in current federal energy R&D budgets.
Likewise, the total investments in a new clean energy economy, more broadly defined, are an order of magnitude smaller than proposals advanced by the Breakthrough Institute, Apollo Alliance and others have deemed necessary to drive clean energy innovation, create millions of new energy jobs, and jump-start a prosperous, clean energy economy.
Below the fold, you can see how the clean energy investments made by the ACES bill compare with what a range of proposals and current R&D funding levels...
The first graph focuses on clean energy R&D only. The second looks at clean energy investments more broadly, including investments to demonstrate, commercialize and deploy clean energy technologies, build critical infrastructure, and even spur energy efficiency improvements. In including investments in carbon capture and storage technology in these totals, I am no doubt being more generous with the term "clean energy" than many of my green colleagues would be, but I include this investment here, just as the ACES bill's authors and champions do. In short, the second graph represents "clean energy investments," broadly defined.
So, do you think ACES clean energy investments pass the grade?
(Click any of these to enlarge...)
Sources and Notes:
[1] See "First Analysis of Waxman-Markey Cap & Trade Allocation," Breakthrough Institute (May 15, 2009).
[2] See "Investing in the Next Generation of Energy Technologies," WhiteHouse.gov. President Obama pledges to "Invest $150 billion over ten years in energy research and development to transition to a clean energy economy."
[3] Forthcoming, May 2009.
[4] See "Top Energy Scientists Call for $30 Bi Annual Investment in Clean Energy," Breakthrough Institute (December 3, 2007). Call for $30 billion in clean energy technology investments
[5] See Energy Discovery-Innovation Institutes: A Step toward America's Energy Sustainability. Brookings Institution (February 9, 2009).
[6] See "Budget and Performance," U.S. Department of Energy.
[7] See "Detailed Summary of Energy Investments in Stimulus," Breakthrough Institute (February 13, 2009).
[8] See "R&D in the FY2009 Budget," American Association for the Advancement of Science (March 23, 2009).
[9] See "New Apollo Program," Apollo Alliance (March 20, 2009).
[10] See "Fast, Clean, & Cheap: Cutting Global Warming's Gordian Knot," Harvard Law and Policy Review. Breakthrough Institute (January 2008).
Originally posted at the Breakthrough Institute
Monday, May 18, 2009
Climate Bill's Clean Energy R&D Investments May Be 30 Times Smaller than President Obama's Budget
Friday, May 15, 2009
Waxman-Markey Gives Nearly 5 Times More to Polluters than Clean Energy
By Teryn Norris & Jesse Jenkins
The landmark Waxman-Markey 2009 American Clean Energy and Security Act was introduced in the House this afternoon (May 15, download PDF here), and the Breakthrough Institute has performed a preliminary analysis of how it would invest over $1 trillion in cap and trade revenue between 2012-2025. Our key findings for this period include (all numbers are approximate -- download spreadsheet here):
(click image to magnify)
- Polluting industries: 57.3% of allowances would be freely distributed to polluting industries, including 36.7% for the electricity sector, 12.3% for energy-intensive industries, 6.5% for local natural gas distribution companies, and 1.8% for oil refiners
- Direct consumer protection: 16.5% of allowances would be used for direct consumer protection, including 15% for low and moderate-income families and 1.5% to benefit users of home heating oil and propane
- Energy efficiency and clean energy technology: 12.2% of allowances would be used to fund energy efficiency and clean energy technology development and deployment
- Adaptation and technology transfer: 4.7% of allowances would be used for domestic and global climate adaptation and technology transfer
- Workforce development: 0.6% of allowances would be used to fund worker assistance and job training
- Deficit reduction and other: 8.6% of allowances would be used to fund deficit reduction and other public purposes
Read more!
Wednesday, May 13, 2009
Climate Bill Heading for Markup - Will it Invest in a Clean, Prosperous Energy Economy?
As sweeping climate and clean energy legislation is readied for debate in the House Energy and Commerce Committee, details are emerging on the deals and compromises struck between the bill's architects, Congressmen Henry Waxman (D-CA) and Ed Markey (D-MA) and the group of reluctant swing members of the committee who hail largely from states reliant on coal and heavy industry.
The "breakthrough deal" struck between Waxman, Markey and the swing E&C Committee Dems will enable a full subcommittee markup of the American Clean Energy and Security Act (ACES) beginning Thursday and likely proceeding through next week (markup = votes on a series of amendments on the proposed bill followed vote to pass the bill out of (sub)committee). The deal apparently involves a series of concessions that either incrementally weaken the objectives of the bill or give free greenhouse gas pollution permits to utilities and heavy industry in order to blunt the impact of the proposed cap and trade program on these sectors of the economy.
The concessions reportedly include:
Other changes (concessions) are obviously possible as well. Full details will emerge Thursday when the bill is official introduced to the subcommittee.
What's clear is that the ACES bill will transfer huge sums of money from energy consumers to utilities and heavy industry. A quick back of the envelope calculation gives us a sense of the scale here: the free allocations to utilities and industry will amount to roughly $215 billion to $561 billion in value between 2012 and 2020 alone (assumes 46-60% of allowances allocated for free, as per concessions above, and $10-20 average CO2 price between 2012 and 2020, click here to download Excel spreadsheet with full calculations).
So with hundreds of billions of dollars on the table for entrenched interests of the dirty energy past, where are the investments needed to spark the birth of a new clean, prosperous energy economy?
Will the ACES bill released tomorrow make the investments in clean energy technology President Obama has repeatedly called for (at least $15b/year for clean tech R&D)? Will it make critical investments to spur the deployment of clean energy technologies necessary to complement the carbon price (meager as it will be) established by the bill? Will it make investments needed to bring down capital barriers holding back countless cost-effective energy efficiency opportunities or make the investments necessary to build a modern, 21st century energy infrastructure?
If it doesn't, will climate advocates rally to ensure that these critical investments are made?
The challenge we face is this: pushing back on the wasteful pollution permit giveaways is great (and will certainly feel good), but is unlikely to yield any results. These giveaways were necessary to bring on key votes, and if the bill's champions yank them back, ACES will almost certainly die in committee. So while climate advocates work to push back against the giveaway of hundreds of billions of dollars to polluters and entrenched energy industries, we must zero in on one key opportunity:To dramatically strengthen ACES and ensure the bill truly spurs the growth of new clean energy technologies and industries, achieves critical emissions reduction targets, and creates millions of new clean energy jobs, the bulk of the remaining auction revenue must be dedicated to investments that accelerate the transition to a clean, prosperous energy economy.
This is perhaps the last, best chance to strengthen the ACES bill. We can't afford to let it slip by.
Originally posted at the Breakthrough Institute
"Cash for Clunkers" No Good in Present Form
Cross-posted from Focus the Nation
Democrats in the House Energy and Commerce Committee have been very busy lately. They’ve been busy, that is, making ACES into what may become a completely worthless bill, in an effort to buy the votes of industrial state moderates in Congress.
A particularly painful example of this is the “cash for clunkers” arrangement that will spend as much as $4.5 billion in taxpayer money to subsidize the purchase of marginally more efficient new vehicles for up to one million drivers. This program creates perverse incentives, does not create cost effective emissions reductions, and is in effect a multi-billion dollar redistribution of taxpayer money to car manufacturers and new car buyers. The new cars don’t even have to be fuel efficient by any reasonable standards.
In the most glaringly awful example of this arrangement’s ridiculousness, someone trading in a large light duty truck for one that gets one mile per gallon better fuel economy (YES, ONLY ONE MPG!), is eligible for a $3,500 voucher toward their new vehicle purchase (YES, THAT’S THREE THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS!).
This is ludicrous.
Even the least unreasonable part of the arrangement, providing a $4,500 voucher to consumers who swap out an old vehicle for one that is 10mpg more efficient, with a minimum efficiency of 22mpg (YES, ONLY 22MPG!), is an absurdly expensive way to reduce emissions and a waste of taxpayer dollars.
What does this mean in practice? I could swap out my Hummer for a Suburban and get $3,500 for it. Or, I could buy an old clunker for $2,000, then “trade it in” for my new car purchase, get a $4,500 voucher, and in effect save $2,500 for buying the same car I could have anyway.
To make matters worse, this bill discriminates against two classes of people: low-income people, who generally don’t buy new cars if they drive at all, and people who don’t use cars for transportation. Both of these populations are responsible for much fewer emissions than high-income people and drivers, respectively, and often people fall into both categories. This means this policy would take money out of low-income, low-emitting citizens pockets and put it into the pockets of higher-income people buying new cars, that only have to get a minimum of 22mpg, and the car companies that make these cars.
This is a perverse idea, and unless it translates directly to votes to pass a solid bill that manages carbon emissions, and I assume Mr. Waxman and Mr. Markey think it will, because I consider them smart men and shrewd legislators, it must be eliminated.
Alternatively, it could be done well by offering the incentive only for genuinely efficient vehicles, including provisions to be sure car buyers don’t take advantage of the perverse incentive to acquire a “clunker” just for the voucher, and providing some incentive for people who already choose not to drive.
For the record, my 1994 Toyota Corolla gets about 25mpg city and 35mpg highway, and I usually ride my bike to work.
Monday, May 11, 2009
Start-Ups Rise to Push Solar on College Campuses

Universities are on the cutting edge of solar energy research, but they’re surprisingly laggard when it comes to adopting it.
Only nine campuses have installed systems producing more than 1 megawatt of electricity, and even those system are making only a tiny dent in their campus power supplies. The 1.2 MW system at the University of California San Diego, for one, generates less than 4% of campus energy use. Dozens of other campuses have smaller solar projects, but among them, only 27 top 100 kilowatts.
Compare our nation’s universities with Wal-Mart, and the numbers are pitiful. Wal-Mart has 18 large arrays in California alone, and it just announced it will double that number in the next 18 months.
So why are universities so slow to jump on solar?
Certainly they could benefit from the carbon-reduction points they’ll earn under the University and College President’s Climate Commitment, a pledge that 633 institutions are now bound to. Solar is also an outstanding educational vehicle for students, especially those eyeing 21st century green jobs. And we mustn’t forget, PV makes great fodder for glossy recruitment pamphlets.
The answer is perhaps best explained by the handful of NGOs and for-profit consulting firms that have popped up to advance the market for solar in higher ed.
They pare the issue down to this: University decision-making moves at a glacial pace, and speedy private-sector solar firms have plenty of other business they can move on with for-profit velocity. It simply hasn’t been worth it for solar firms to work with campuses – until now.
That untapped market and the lost opportunity for universities are precisely what compelled Jacob Travis, founder of the newly launched Solar College Initiative, to get involved in the solar biz after years in academia.
“There’s a fundamental issue – after a certain point, it just doesn’t remain profitable for solar firms to work with universities because the decision-making and contracting period tends to take forever. By streamlining the evaluation and contracting phases, we hope to create a ‘solar pipeline’, where numerous firms will be jumping at the chance to offer ripe universities the best solar deal they can get. It’s a total win-win.”This article has been cross-posted from SolveClimate.com. To read the rest of the article, click here. Read more!
Labels:
education,
higher ed,
renewable energy,
solar,
youth activism
Thursday, May 07, 2009
DOE Budget Fleshes out Obama Energy Education Initiative
New details on President Obama's RE-ENERGYSE energy education initiative, which mirrors closely Breakthrough's National Energy Education Act proposal. Is the new program large enough to truly prepare a new generation to tackle the greatest innovation challenge this nation has ever faced?
Originally posted at the Breakthrough Institute
President Obama and the Department of Energy are launching a new energy education initiative, very similar to the National Energy Education Act recommendations advanced by the Breakthrough Institute beginning in June 2008 (see recent post here). Today, the Department of Energy released official FY 2010 budget documents that start to flesh out what this new program will look like. It appears the program will receive $115 million in funding, if the President's budget request is implemented.
Here's the description of the program from the new 'Budget Highlights' document available here (pdf):
RE-ENERGYSE (REgaining our ENERGY Science and Engineering Edge)Later, the document specifies that $80 million will be dedicated to higher ed initiatives, while the remaining $35 million will focus on technical training as well as K12 eduction efforts (see p. 30).
The Department will launch a comprehensive K-20+ science and engineering initiative, funded at $115 million in FY 2010, to educate thousands of students at all levels in the fields contributing to the fundamental understanding of energy science and engineering systems. This initiative, which complements the Department's other education efforts, will provide graduate research fellowships in scientific and technical fields that advance the Department's energy mission; provide training grants to universities that establish multidisciplinary research and education programs related to clean energy; support universities that dramatically expand energy-related research opportunities for undergraduates; build partnerships between community colleges and different segments of the clean tech industry to develop customized curriculum for "green collar" jobs; and increase public awareness, particularly among young people, about the role that science and technology can play in responsible environmental stewardship.
Later, the document specifies that $80 million will be dedicated to higher ed initiatives, while the remaining $35 million will focus on technical training as well as K12 eduction efforts (see p. 30).
A presentation on the budget delivered by Secretary of Energy Steven Chu is also posted online (pdf). The brief slide deck highlights the new RE-ENERGYSE initiative and appears to indicate the number of students the program will support at different grade levels in a chart shown here:
The Workforce Development for Teachers and Scientists program is an existing DOE education program managed by the Office of Science to engage and support young scientists and science educators, including internships and fellowships to perform work alongside experience researchers at National Labs. The 2010 budget request includes a 52% increase in funding for this program as well, a $7 million increase over FY 2009, bringing the programs budget to $20.7 million.
The new energy education initiative will be a joint program between DOE and the National Science Foundation (NSF). Further details and funding levels for NSF's portion of the program will likely appear in the FY 2010 NSF budget request, but the agency apparently canceled a briefing it was scheduled to hold today on the new budget.
Initial commentary:
The new RE-ENERGYSE program is the right kind of program at exactly the right time. We applaud President Obama and Secretary Chu for advancing this critical energy education initiative.
President Obama's higher eduction priorities and the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act have both worked to expand overall access to higher eduction as well, just as the National Defense Education Act did in the 1960s. However, if we want to ensure that students are both inspired and empowered to engage in energy innovation and enter fields central to our national energy challenges, a major effort is needed.
The scale of the new RE-ENERGYSE program must grow quickly to truly prepare a new generation of scientists, entrepreneurs and engineers to tackle the energy innovation challenge. Reaching just 1,735 undergrads and 660 graduate students and post-docs seems too small to have a transformative impact on the educational arena we need. For a sense of scale, 17 million Americans are currently enrolled in institutes of higher eduction, as we noted in the National Energy Education Act proposal (available here, pdf).
This kind of program is exactly what's needed. While a smaller, pilot scale may make sense as the new initiative launches, the RE-ENERGYSE program must quickly scale to ensure a new generation of American innovators are ready to rise to the greatest innovation challenge our nation has ever faced: making clean energy cheap and securing a prosperous global clean energy economy.
Read more!
Bjorn Lomborg Wants to Make Clean Energy Cheap, Doesn't Know How
Originally posted at the Breakthrough Institute
Bjorn Lomborg wants to make clean energy cheap. Unfortunately, the author of The Skeptical Environmentalist and Cool It doesn't seem to understand that making clean energy cheap is about much more than R&D.
In an interview on Wednesday with the San Francisco Examiner's Thomas Fuller, Lomborg says:
"I love this thought--it comes from the Breakthrough Institute. Basically, the idea is that everyone seems to be trying to make fossil fuels so expensive that we won't use them. But that's never going to happen. So why don't we try to make green energy so cheap that everyone will want to use it?"He then argues, "We should spend vastly more on research and development."
Lomborg get's that part right. As we've long argued, today's paltry investments in clean energy R&D -- from both public and private sectors alike -- is woefully inadequate to the energy innovation imperative we face today. With a broad expert consensus making the case and politicians from President Obama to Republican Senator Lisa Murkowski (R-AK) calling for more public investment in clean energy R&D, we seem to be approaching the political 'critical mass' necessary for real change on that front.
But for Lomborg, clean energy R&D is something you do instead of deploying clean energy technology available today, and that's where we part ways with "the Skeptical Environmentalist."
What Lomborg apparently doesn't understand is that efforts to truly "make green energy so cheap that everyone will want to use it" will necessarily involve major direct public investments to spur the rapid deployment of emerging clean energy technologies. Far from something that just occurs in the lab, the innovation process extends well beyond R&D.
A Man of Many (False) Trade-offs
Bjorn Lomborg is a man of many trade-offs. In his frequent writings and public appearances, a discussion of supposed trade-offs and their relative costs and benefits is usually at the heart of his arguments.
Lomborg frequently argues that "we shouldn't waste time cutting emissions" and tackling climate change today, because investing in technology innovation will yield cheaper solutions tomorrow (i.e. "by mid-century").
In his interview with the Examiner, Lomborg argues:
"The depressing thing is that everybody talks about green energy, but everybody thinks that means putting up windmills. Putting up very specific windmills. My point is if you actually want to do good, it's not about putting up windmills that are, even now, inefficient, it's about putting up windmills in the future that are so efficient that everybody will want one."Elsewhere, including at great length in his book Cool It, Lomborg runs (arguably contrived) economic calculations to show the costs and benefits of these supposed trade-offs, arguing, for example, that our money would be better spent on fighting infectious diseases like malaria and other "more immediate" threats, instead of trying to stop climate change.
Of course, these trade-offs are really false. When unchecked climate change presents an existential threat to humanity, the choice isn't between taking action and not taking action. The choice is about what course of action to take.
It is, of course, critical to place climate change within the greater context of the global development challenges we face. When we conceptualize climate change as a problem of too little development -- i.e. poor nations relying on affordable (and to date, that means dirty) fuels or the deforestation of vast stretches of rain forests to power their growth and rich nations still too dependent on these antiquated energy technologies -- rather than a problem of human excess and too much development, we can see our way to a more durable and effective path to combating climate change (see the new collection of writings, "The Emerging Climate Consensus" for more on this critical shift in thinking).
But Lomborg is kidding himself (and misleading others) if he thinks we can afford to delay efforts to spur a rapid transition to a global clean energy economy and slash emissions. The science is clear, our time is short, and while investing in R&D will open critical new and affordable pathways to a low-carbon economy, we have no time to waste.
Furthermore, if we're really dedicated to making clean energy cheap, the choice isn't between investing in clean energy R&D or investing in deployment of clean energy technologies. We need to do both, and the question is really how can we best drive deployment to secure improvements in price and performance -- that is, how can deployment make clean energy cheap, even as we begin to cut emissions.
Lomborg Isn't Alone in Embracing a False Trade-Off Between Innovation and Deployment
Lomborg is, unfortunately, right about one thing: climate advocates have all too often focused on policies to deploy today's technologies while giving short shrift to critical efforts to spur clean technology innovation. And when they do so, they fall into the exact same tragic false dichotomy Lomborg himself plays up.
Take Climate Progress' Joe Romm as a case study. Romm steadfastly maintains that no significant technological innovation is needed to tackle the climate challenge and transform the entire global energy system. Instead, it's all about "deploy, deploy deploy." And we've all heard the oft-repeated myth "we have all the technologies we need, all we lack is the political will" issued from the mouth of numerous climate advocates.
These arguments are politically motivated, however, and stand at odds with the overwhelming expert consensus that the scale of the energy and climate challenge demands dramatic and transformative innovation.
For climate advocates who've seen far too many arguments from the likes of Lomborg and the Bush Administration that we should delay action while we wait for cheaper, more convenient technologies to emerge from labs, it's hard to embrace the energy innovation imperative. Acknowledging the clear need for greatly accelerated energy innovation is assumed to be a political weakness.
This is a mistake. The scale of our energy challenge clearly demands both accelerated deployment of clean energy technology and an order-of-magnitude increase in public investment in clean energy innovation. Expert consensus is unwavering on that front.
The assumption that we need to have all of the technologies on the shelf today to even begin the decade's long transformation of the global energy systems is a pernicious trap, one that should be rejected outright, not tacitly accepted, as climate advocates do when they embrace the "we have all the technologies we need" myth.
Furthermore, a robust clean energy innovation strategy would strengthen, not weaken the political support for the kinds of renewable energy standards and carbon caps climate advocates call for. Supporting the innovation necessary to produce the steady supply of affordable technologies needed to meet these regulations is critical to securing the sustained political support they will need over the decades ahead. It's time for climate advocates to put our money where our mandates are.
Technology Deployment to Make Clean Energy Cheap
In the realm of energy policy, innovation and deployment are typically viewed as two separate and distinct domains. This is hardly the case.
In a 2006 paper available here, energy innovation expert Dr. Greg Nemet explored the various factors leading to the steady decline in price experienced by solar photovoltaic technology over the past decades. What he found is summarized in the following table:
Essentially, Nemet discovered four primary factors contributing to the remarkable factor of 26 drop in price experienced by photovoltaic technology between 1975 and 2001 (the period he studies):
- Economies of scale - e.g. the size of manufacturing plants - responsible for 43% of the price reductions;
- R&D breakthroughs - e.g. improved photovoltaic cell efficiency and new cell manufacturing processes - responsible for 32% of the price reductions;
- Learning by doing effects - e.g. reduced silicon usage, higher yields, etc. - which contributed to a variety of factors responsible for about 10% of the price reductions;
- Spill-over of technology advances pioneered in other industries - e.g. lower silicon supply costs due to advances spurred by the microchip industry - contributing to factors responsible for about 15% of the price reductions.
The lesson should be clear: innovation doesn't stop at the lab, nor do the factors driving down the price of clean energy technologies. Both R&D and deployment were critical to driving down the price of solar cells, and both strategies are essential to make clean energy cheap.
This means it's time to reject the false dichotomy between R&D and deployment -- whether advanced by Bjorn Lomborg or green climate advocates -- and see both as part of an interconnected innovation process. A strategy to make clean energy cheap must embrace the accelerated deployment of emerging technologies and design effective policies to do so.
These policies should focus not just on quantity -- getting megawatts in the ground -- but technology performance as well -- i.e. driving reductions in the real, unsubsidized price of emerging clean energy technologies. And they should come from a clear understanding of the various factors driving improvements in price and performance.
This has not been the case with many (if not most) of the deployment policies implemented to date, including the renewable energy production or investments tax credits and renewable portfolio standards popular in America as well as the feed-in tariffs spurring clean energy across Europe. Price improvements may be an incidental and welcome side-effect of the economies of scale supported by these policies, but it's far from their central thrust. How to best drive price improvement and technology performance is therefore given little (if any) consideration in the design of these deployment policies.
Making clean energy cheap and overcoming the urgency climate challenge will require much more intentional policy design. We can afford such laxity no longer.
Read more!
Economists: Clean Energy beats Dirty Coal in the South
Guest post by JW Randolph, originally posted at Appalachian Voices' "Front Porch" blog...
Great news for the struggling economy of Appalachia and the South…
Washington, DC: The experts behind a group of new reports summarized their findings today showing that new coal plants present serious financial risks to southern utilities and ratepayers, especially in light on looming federal regulations on carbon dioxide emissions.
“Our analyses have shown that uncertainty about future coal plant construction costs and the costs of complying with impending federal regulation of plant carbon dioxide emissions represent significant risks for utilities and their customers,” said David Schlissel, a Senior Consultant for Synapse Energy Economics. “In particular, the federal government is likely to mandate significant reductions in carbon dioxide emissions. The costs of complying with this expected federal action are likely to increase the cost of generating power at new coal-fired plants by tens to hundreds of millions of dollars each year, making coal an even more expensive option than energy efficiency and renewable resources.”
Citing a growing body of evidence, which includes financial reports from Virginia, South Carolina, Kentucky and Louisiana, the experts highlighted the clear economic benefits of renewable energies and energy efficiency in the South, and across the Nation.
Michael Fisher, Vice President and Principal Associate of Abt Associates, which authored the Virginia report found that, “Investments in energy efficiency are considerably less expensive and more beneficial to the Virginia economy than building a new coal-fired power plant to meet Virginia’s energy needs.”…
“The relative economic gains to Virginia from energy efficiency investments are substantial, with Gross State Product increasing by upwards of a billion dollars annually and employment increasing by over 5,000 new jobs,” continued Fisher.
In all of the reports, the findings clearly indicated that new coal-fired power plants were not needed.
“In our analysis of East Kentucky Power Cooperative we found the proposed Smith coal plant was not originally approved on the basis of the demand for electricity, but rather for business needs. Since then energy demand has slowed considerably and the need for the plant is even less. Now, with changes in federal policies, the plant serves no purpose at all. In baseball, three strikes means you’re out. The Smith coal plant would be a highly polluting, expensive, and unnecessary burden on Kentucky ratepayers,” said Tom Sanzillo, a Senior Associate with TR Rose Associates.
“These reports make it clear that the South is not an exception,” said Mark Kresowik, Corporate Accountability Representative for the Sierra Club. “Coal plants are simply a poor investment, no matter where in the country you are building them. We need to be investing wisely, especially in these economic times, and that means looking at energy efficiency and renewable energy projects that can create jobs and help fight global warming, without the drawbacks of coal.”
###
Related Reports and Resources:
Old Dominion Electric Cooperative’s Hampton Roads Power Plant, Virginia
http://wiseenergyforvirginia.org/resources/
Santee Cooper’s Pee Dee Power Plant, South Carolina
http://coastalconservationleague.org/Page.aspx?pid=842
East Kentucky Power Cooperative’s Smith Power Plant, Kentucky
http://kentucky.sierraclub.org/Resources/Environmental_Research/RightDecision/FullReport.pdf
Dominion Resources’ Wise County Power Plant, Virginia
http://www.wiseenergyforvirginia.org/downloads/WisePowerReport0309.pdf












