Energy Collective blog power policy climate - the conversation happens here

Wednesday, July 01, 2009

Kowalski: Relieved ACES Climate Bill Passed But It Doesn't Do Enough, Fast Enough,

This week, WattHead has featured a number of reactions to the passage of the American Clean Energy and Security Act last Friday, particularly from young climate leaders. 1Sky's policy expert Jason Kowalski appeared on Al Jazeera this week to discuss the bill's passage and the hard work ahead to enact U.S. climate policy that can truly solve the climate crisis. Check it out:



See also:

  • "ACES In the House: Job, Well, Done." by Alex Tinker
  • "What Happened on Friday" by Morgan Goodwin
  • "Reflections on redefining ACES from out in the sticks" by Timothy Den Herder Thomas
  • Teryn Norris goes toe to toe with Henry Waxman on Montel Williams Across America
  • "Jesse Jenkins on KPFA: Is the Climate Change Bill in Danger of Being Ineffective?"
  • Read more!

    Tuesday, June 30, 2009

    Brookings Institution: Senate Must Strengthen Clean Energy Funding in ACES


    By Johanna Peace, Breakthrough Fellow

    The American Clean Energy and Security Act (ACES) that passed by a margin of 219-212 in the House on Friday needs a major makeover in the Senate in order to redress its critically insufficient provisions for funding clean energy R&D, according to Mark Muro, policy director at the Brookings Institution's Metropolitan Policy Program.

    In a Brookings article criticizing the climate bill, Muro argues:

    "While a $20 to $30 billion a year R&D outlay would be optimal, Waxman-Markey would invest just 1.5 percent of the 40-year revenue stream of the cap-and-trade system in the R&D efforts of ARPA-E and the innovation hubs--which comes to just $1.4 billion a year or so at accepted permit price forecasts... The bottom line: Reps. Waxman and Markey did well to install several crucial innovation provisions in the House bill, but the political trades that were required to pass it have left far too little revenue behind for the most crucial use of cap-trade money--investments to catalyze a radically cleaner energy future."
    Muro's points reaffirm Breakthrough Institute's analysis, which has shown how ACES invests far more cap and trade revenue in polluting industries and foreign offsets than it does in building new clean energy industries in the U.S.

    Muro mentions that some ACES provisions -- such as the funding it would direct toward ARPA-E and the eight regional "Energy Innovation Hubs" it would establish -- constitute a modest start toward the kind of public investment that will promote the development and commercialization of clean energy technologies. Breakthrough Institute, too, has pointed to some of the same provisions as promising -- but only if they are adequately funded.

    But they're not. Important as their mere presence may be, these tiny "slivers of the 40-year revenue stream" of the ACES cap and trade system remain a "paltry" fraction of the public investment the United States will need to propel a transition to a prosperous, clean energy economy.

    As Muro writes, all of this translates into a "major task" for the Senate as it begins to confront the woefully inadequate climate bill handed to it by the House:
    "By applying to the cause a long-term revenue stream, the Senate should significantly strengthen Waxman-Markey's clean energy R&D provisions, principally by investing significantly more in them. To be sure nothing will be easy here. Not only is the Senate far less "fired up" on balance to act aggressively on climate. Also, the Senate is addressing climate and energy in a more fragmented way, with Sen. Boxer's liberal-leaning Environment and Public Works Committee developing a greenhouse gas and cap-and-trade regime while Sen. Bingaman's more centrist Energy and Natural Resources Committee advances renewable energy, efficiency standards, and smart grid proposals in a regular bill.

    In that splintered context, it's going to require difficult negotiations to get a Senate bill and then to reconcile it with ACES. And yet, it does not seem fanciful to suggest that heavy investment in energy innovation and economic transformation could offer the best route forward. Such investments need to emerge as the needed point of consensus between the greenest of the greens and stalwart defenders of the nation's economic competitiveness, first in the Senate and then in both Houses. Only through that convergence will the nation gain a truly transformative energy and climate bill that moves the nation soundly toward clean energy economy."

    Read more!

    Join WattHead's Jesse Jenkins for Webinar on ACES Climate Bill Thursday

    WattHead readers are invited to join me and fellow Energy Collective blogger and environmental economist John Whitehead for a webinar (or "twebinar": we'll be taking live questions via Twitter) on the American Clean Energy and Security Act this Thursday. Details below:

    The Energy Collective Webcast: What Will ACES Achieve?

    Tune in Thursday, July 2 at 12:00 EST

    The U.S. House of Representatives voted on Friday to pass the American Clean Energy and Security Act, commonly known as the Waxman-Markey Bill. While it has yet to pass the Senate, the bill promises an unprecedented and sweeping package of climate legislation, the full ramifications of which are yet to be determined.

    But will the bill actually accomplish all of its purported goals? And how? What effects, short and long-term, will the bill actually have on the U.S. economy and the current path of climate change?

    The Energy Collective presents a live, interactive webcast in which energy experts and TEC blogger board members Jesse Jenkins of the Breakthrough Institute and John C. Whitehead of Appalachian State University will dig into the bill and provide insight into its likely effectiveness in a number of key areas. Participants will have the opportunity to participate and ask questions by following along on twitter with the hashtag #talkaces.

    Don't miss this opportunity to participate in a live, in-depth discussion with other energy experts and aficionados. Dial in Thursday at 12:00 EST at:

    Toll Free Number: 1.800.868.1837
    Access Code: 74378755#

    And discuss online on twitter with the tag: #talkaces

    Read more!

    Monday, June 29, 2009

    What Happened on Friday

    Cross-posted from ItsGettingHotInHere and DailyKos

    I walked out of the US Capitol on Friday evening just as a torrential downpour started. The sky opened up, and all the humid DC air released its pent-up energy in a big, blustery storm of thunder, lightning, and horizontal rain. It was a fitting conclusion to a very intense and stressful week of working on climate legislation.

    The entire day was a long and crazy adventure in politics. I started my morning at 8am in a demonstration in front of the White House in anticipation of Angela Merkel's visit with President Obama. The Avaaz Action Factory had giant green hard hats and cut-outs of the two leaders were there to show the domestic and international press that Americans expect a lot more from both leaders. Read more about that action here, and see the coverage in the Boston Globe.


    But my day wasn't over. After heading back to my house to read updates on the climate bill and send off some tweets urging DC folks to come to our afternoon rally, I left with our van of props for the Capitol. That rally, organized by the Energy Action Coalition and Chesapeake Climate Action Network and the Avaaz Action Factory had been thrown together in 2 days with news of the upcoming vote with one major goal: insert ourselves into the climate debate as saying, "We want more!" (Photo in WSJ).



    So by the time I left the Capitol, I had participated in two actions, led a team of young people in green shirts through the Capitol to remind reps of where the youth stand (in favor of a STRONG climate bill) and then sat in the gallery for an hour with 40 youth leaders watching the circus that is Congress.

    I anxiously watched those votes come up on the basketball-style scoreboard, as the Yea's were at 185, and then 204, and then 209, and then 214, and then 217, 218, and finally 219. And that was it, one of the most powerful assemblies in the world had just voted to reduce emissions in the United States --a truly historic achievement. But I couldn't celebrate at all, because no matter how historic this event was, it is not based on science, it is not a measure that seeks to urgently safeguard the most vulnerable people in this country and this world. And it is not a bill that moves us directly or boldly towards a clean energy economy.

    Supporting this bill in the past few weeks, and working for its passage, was the lesser of two evils. We were stuck with a very mediocre bill, but we were also faced with the prospect of climate legislation being ‘defeated.’ After 8 years of climate denial, defeat of this bill would destroy what little momentum we have gained in congress, But in supporting such a shoddy bill, I sincerely hope that we haven't sacrificed too much. Among my activist friends, the questions have flown back and forth: 'How weak will you let it get and still support it?', 'Is it better than doing nothing?', 'Does this help get a strong enough treaty in Copenhagen?', 'Will this do anything to end the injustice of coal mining or tar sands or prevent a new derivatives market?', 'How can a climate bill give so much money to the coal industry?'

    I can't reply to most of those questions directly because I'm not proud of the answer. Instead, I have to respond with different lines of argument: this process cannot stall out here, because we would lose years of not doing anything. We didn't have a tidal wave of public opinion calling for a climate bill, but rather left Waxman and Markey to fight for this legislation largely without presidential support or intense grassroots demand.

    A few weeks ago it became apparent that this bill was not going to get strengthened in the House, and reps were going to be largely left with just a Yes or No vote. At that point, many of us realized we had been naively led into the trap of supporting the bill's sponsors, instead of creating a clear demand for more with the threat of not settling for less. Creating that strong demand should be the work of the grassroots movement, which we didn't create coming into this. I'm thinking about how we can build for the next time around.

    I'm very proud of the actions that I helped to organize around the bill. But now it’s time to quickly regroup and form a much stronger position around the things that we are not willing to compromise around. I agree with Alex Tinker’s recent blog post--

    "If ACES does not get a whole lot stronger in the Senate, it is time to kill the bill. Kill the bill and start over, or kill the bill and let EPA use its authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions. Of those options, I strongly prefer the former." -link

    I will not support a bill that is as weak as this in the Senate. Furthermore, the bill needs to allocate 5% of auction revenues each to reducing emissions from deforestation and degradation internationally, international clean-tech transfer, and international climate adaptation. The world is looking to the US for 15% of revenue to go to these international leadership areas, and currently only 7% is spread over them. The bill needs to invest a lot more in renewables in a way that catapults their development forward much faster than 'business as usual.’

    The frame of this bill needs to be changed, from 'How do we tackle this problem while causing as little change as possible?,' to 'How can we be transformational?.'

    I walked out of the capitol in a very reflective mood, but over the weekend the path ahead has become much clearer. We need to be clear that we will not settle for anything less than a transformational piece of legislation that reflects the urgency of the crisis we are in, not to mention the opportunity that a very different future provides.

    Read more!

    Rep. Waxman Responds to Breakthrough Institute, Criticizing Public Investment and Praising Offsets

    Earlier today, Congressman Henry Waxman was asked to directly respond to the Breakthrough Institute's analysis of the American Clean Energy & Security Act (ACES) during an interview on the Montel Williams Across America radio show. His segment came after my interview on the same show, where I highlighted Breakthrough's analysis and spoke about some of our concerns with the bill.

    Here is a transcript of his response (starting at 8:00 minutes, podcast available here). Rep. Waxman is Chairman of the House Committee on Energy and Commerce and lead author of the ACES climate bill:

    Montel Williams: "Teryn Norris from the Breakthrough Institute and several other people say that this [bill] is based on credits that would be given out and traded by companies to meet their carbon footprint - I'm being told that 85% of these are being given away when they could have been auctioned off, which would have been a revenue source that could have been put toward more forms of renewable energy. Why did we decide to give away these credits rather than auction them off?"

    Congressman Waxman: "We're giving away the credits to utilities in order to protect ratepayers. The credits they won't have to pay for won't be charged to ratepayers, both individual consumers and businesses... So this is a way to be fair to the consumers.

    The essence of the legislation is that we're going to get reductions and we're going to have a limit on carbon emissions and those limits go down. As we try to squeeze down the amount of carbon year after year we want it done in a way that hurts the consumers as little as possible and we think for the most part we've protected most people. And we want it done in a way that can produce the result in the least expensive way, so there are offsets that can be purchased.


    It doesn't make a difference that a coal-burning powerplant has to reduce its emissions if they have to do it by reducing their own coal, that could be more costly than just buying an offset and we still get the same environmental result. The environmental result is achieved, we do it in a way that would impact the economy in the easiest manner, and at the same time we're providing renewable fuels and greater efficiency and opportunities to get cars on the road that will pollute less.

    It's going to transform our economy and in the whole process it's going to produce I think millions of new jobs, it's going to unleash investments that could be as much of an incentive and stimulus to our economy as anything the government could do, it's going to do more than the stimulus we passed because the investments are going to be made in the private sector."
    Stay tuned for an upcoming post where Breakthrough Institute will address Rep. Waxman's points. To begin, however, it is worth noting that Rep. Waxman asserts that freely distributing carbon allowances produces the same environmental result as full auctioning and is specifically designed to protect ratepayers. Why, then, did President Obama and his Budget Director recently state the following about the importance of auctioning allowances?
    Peter Orszag: "If you didn't auction the permit, it would represent the largest corporate welfare program that has ever been enacted in the history of the United States. In particular, all of the evidence suggests that what would occur is the corporate profits would increase by approximately the value of the permit."

    President Obama: "If you're giving away carbon permits for free, then basically you're not really pricing the thing and it doesn't work -- or people can game the system in so many ways that it's not creating the incentive structures that we're looking for"

    Read more!

    Jenkins on KPFA: Is the Climate Change Bill in Danger of Being Ineffective?

    Last Wednesday, June 23rd, I was a guest on KPFA radio's Morning Show to discuss the shape of the Waxman-Markey American Clean Energy and Security Act. Two days later, the 1,300 page climate and energy legislation passed the U.S. House of Representatives by a vote of 219-212 on Friday evening.

    The segment with Morning Show host Amy Allison begins at 1:10:00 into the show which you can listen to below or click here to download an mp3 of the segment and listen on your computer:

    The Morning Show - June 23, 2009 at 7:00am

    Click to listen (or download)

    Read more!

    Obama Energy Promises Not Matched by House Energy Bill

    By Michael Shellenberger and Ted Nordhaus. Originally posted at the Breakthrough Institute

    Since he launched his campaign for president in 2007, President Barack Obama has promised legislation that would deliver more clean energy jobs through the creation of new and larger clean energy industries, like solar and wind manufacturing, to drive future economic growth. On Tuesday and again yesterday, Obama claimed that climate legislation to be voted on as early as tomorrow in the House of Representatives legislation "will create a set of incentives that will spur the development of new sources of energy, including wind, solar, and geothermal power."

    But analyses by the Environmental Protection Agency, the Union of Concerned Scientists, the Breakthrough Institute, and others show that the Waxman Markey climate legislation will not significantly grow the number of clean energy jobs or industries. The EPA analysis released on the same day as Obama's speech shows that the deployment of renewables could be less than without the legislation. An analysis of the renewable energy standard (RES) provision of the legislation by the Union of Concerned Scientists, whose model of various RES exemptions is the most thorough, finds that the legislation could actually require less renewables deployment than projected to occur under the U.S. Energy Information Administration's conservative business-as-usual forecasts. And EPA says the impact of the legislation on gasoline prices ($0.13 a gallon in 2015, $.25 in 2030) will be too small to motivate consumers to drive less or buy smaller cars, or provide incentive for the automotive industry to produce more fuel efficient and technologically advanced vehicles like plug-in hybrid cars.

    While the White House web site still promises $15 billion annually for clean energy R&D alone, the House climate legislation would invest just $800 million to 1.4 billion in R&D. Total investments in clean energy, defined broadly, are likely to be just $6-9 billion annually between 2012-2025, in contrast to the $30-60 billion annually that will be transferred to utilities, coal-fired power plant operators, oil refiners, natural gas distributors and heavy industry under the bill, and the $15-30 billion annually that would flow overseas to pay for international offsets if they are utilized at the full levels permitted by the legislation.

    Leading energy experts on Thursday sent a letter to President Obama and members of Congress calling for a massive increase in money set aside in the climate legislation for energy research and development. Quoting President Obama's statements calling for a vibrant national clean energy industry, the scientists write that "Large public investments in technology innovation have been critical for establishing America's leadership in the aerospace, computer, Internet, and pharmaceutical industries -- and they will be critical to establishing America's leadership in clean energy."

    The legislation will be voted on at a time when China, Korea, and Japan are all investing large sums to create domestic clean energy industries. China will invest $300 -- $600 billion over the next 10 years in solar, wind, nuclear power, high speed rail, and electric cars. South Korea, with an economy 1/10th the size of the U.S., has pledged to spend $40 billion over the next four years on renewable energy programs. And Japan, which already leads the world in hybrid engine and solar panel technologies, has pledged to cut its domestic reduction of carbon emissions, already among the lowest in the world on a GDP per capita basis, a further 15% through the deployment of renewable energy technology. The three nations meet in August to develop a strategy to combine China's low-cost manufacturing the Korea and Japan's engineering know-how.

    Read more!

    Letter to Obama & Congress: $30 billion Annually Needed for Energy Technology


    By Teryn Norris, originally posted at the Breakthrough Institute

    Leading energy experts from across the country sent a letter to President Obama and members of Congress on Thursday calling for a massive increase in clean energy investments included in the American Clean Energy & Security Act.

    "We express our profound concern about the abysmal funding for energy technology innovation in the Waxman-Markey American Clean Energy and Security (ACES) Act," the energy experts wrote. "As it stands, this Act ignores President Obama's consistent call for investing $150 billion over ten years in energy research and development."

    Analysis by the Breakthrough Institute has shown that ACES invests only one-fifteenth of what President Obama has consistently promised for energy R&D. As Michael Shellenberger and Ted Nordhaus wrote today, "While the White House web site still promises $15 billion annually for clean energy R&D alone, the House climate legislation would invest just $800 million to 1.4 billion in R&D."

    The energy experts called for a clean energy RD&D budget of $20-30 billion annually. "Moreover, we believe that at least $30 billion will be needed annually to research, develop, and demonstrate low- and no-carbon energy technologies, with the aim of achieving breakthroughs that can make them much cheaper."

    This letter echoes the recommendations of the Brookings Institution, International Energy Agency, Apollo Alliance, Breakthrough Institute, and others. In late 2007, 30 energy experts including several Nobel Laureates wrote a letter to Congress calling for $30 billion of annual investments in clean energy RD&D.

    The full letter is here:

    Letter to President Obama and Congress:
    On the Need for $30 billion Annually for Energy Technology Innovation


    June 25th, 2009

    Dear President Obama, Speaker Pelosi, Senator Reid, and Members of Congress,

    We express our profound concern about the abysmal funding for energy technology innovation in the Waxman-Markey American Clean Energy and Security (ACES) Act.

    As it stands, this Act ignores President Obama's consistent call for investing $150 billion over ten years in energy research and development.

    Moreover, we believe that at least $30 billion will be needed annually to research, develop, and demonstrate low- and no-carbon energy technologies, with the aim of achieving breakthroughs that can make them much cheaper.

    Large public investments in technology innovation have been critical for establishing America's leadership in the aerospace, computer, Internet, and pharmaceutical industries -- and they will be critical to establishing America's leadership in clean energy.

    Regulations and a price on carbon dioxide -- especially the low price that the Waxman-Markey's ACES bill would establish -- will not be enough to achieve the necessary technological breakthroughs. With a carbon dioxide price of between $10 and $15 per ton, the ACES bill would allocate just $500-$750 million for clean energy research and development (with additional funds directed to commercialization and deployment). In contrast, the bill would allocate $28-$42 billion annually for fossil fuel-reliant energy companies, utilities, and heavy industries.

    On May 27, 2009, President Obama spoke with decisiveness and vision:

    "We have a choice. We can remain the world's leading importer of oil, or we can become the world's leading exporter of clean energy." He continued, "we can hand over the jobs of the future to our competitors, or we can confront what they have already recognized as the great opportunity of our time: the nation that leads the world in creating new sources of clean energy will be the nation that leads the 21st century global economy. That's the nation I want America to be."

    We are writing to ask you to help realize President Obama's vision for the role of clean energy in a prosperous, safe, and independent America. We urge you to support energy innovation, and work to allocate at least $30 billion per year to research, develop and demonstrate clean energy technologies.
    We look forward to hearing your response.

    Sincerely,

    Martin Hoffert
    Physics Professor Emeritus, NYU
    Senior Fellow, Breakthrough Institute

    Ken Caldeira
    Carnegie Institution / Stanford University

    Eric Hoffert
    Versatility, Inc.

    Stephen E. Schwartz
    Brookhaven National Laboratory

    Bill Fulkerson, Senior Fellow
    Institute for a Secure and Sustainable Environment
    University of Tennessee

    William F. Dempster
    Institute of Ecotechnics
    Santa Fe, NM

    Scott Barrett
    Columbia University

    Michael Schlessinger
    University of Illinois

    Greg H. Rau
    University of California, Santa Cruz

    John Turner,
    National Renewable Energy Laboratory

    Geoffrey Landis

    Jane Long
    Lawrence Livermore Laboratory

    Michael MacCracken
    Climate Institute
    Washington, DC

    Mark Jacobson
    Stanford University

    John Katzenberger
    Aspen Global Change Initiative

    Tom Wigley
    University Corporation for Atmospheric Research

    William Dempster

    Michael Mann
    Director, Earth System Science Center (ESSC)
    Pennsylvannia State University

    T. Homer-Dixon
    Center for International Governance Innovation
    University of Waterloo

    David Keith
    University of Calgary

    Darel Preble
    President, Space Solar Power Institute

    *Institutions listed for identification purposes only

    Read more!